Ibiza: Long Before the Party Started

Phoenicians, Pirates and Ancient Seagrass

Show notes

Ibiza isn't just where Europe comes to dance. It has been reinventing itself for nearly 2,700 years. Phoenician settlers named their town after an Egyptian god of music and dance, and salt made the island rich. Pirate raids turned its village churches into fortresses and its old town into a blueprint for Spanish forts across the Atlantic.

Beneath it all, quite literally, lie meadows of Posidonia seagrass that keep the water crystal clear. That raises this episode's big question: do Phoenician tombs, Renaissance walls and an underwater forest really belong together in one World Heritage Site?

Corrections & Clarifications

We're rookies, so we like to keep ourselves honest — a few things from this episode worth clarifying or adding:

How old are the oldest traces? We mentioned cave paintings as evidence of Bronze Age visitors. The island's only rock art, in the Cova de ses Fontanelles, may actually date from the Punic period, roughly the 6th to 4th century BCE. Evidence for people living on Ibiza before the Phoenicians is limited, so "a waypoint for sailors" is a fair way to put it.

When did the Phoenicians arrive, and who is Bes? We said both "654 BCE" and "8th century BCE", and both belong to the same story. According to UNESCO, Sa Caleta goes back to the first Phoenician occupation in the 8th century BCE. 654 BCE is the traditional founding date of the town of Ibiza, "the town of Bes". Around 590 BCE, Sa Caleta was abandoned in favour of the bay of today's Ibiza Town. And for the record, Bes is a he: an Egyptian god.

Ibiza in the 1930s: The artists and intellectuals who found refuge on Ibiza from 1933 onwards were largely fleeing Nazi Germany, not Franco. The Dada artist Raoul Hausmann is the best-known example. Spain's own turn came later: when the Civil War broke out in 1936, Hausmann had to leave the island.

The mixed-site debate: It turns out UNESCO's own advisers asked the same question! Dalt Vila on its own was turned down in 1987. When Spain came back with "Biodiversity and Culture", ICOMOS recommended sending the nomination back, asking for the parts to be treated "as components of an integrated whole". IUCN recommended deferral. In 1999 the Committee inscribed it anyway. What do you think? Tell us at @worldheritagerookies.

What will you learn in this episode?

  • How Phoenician settlers founded Ibiza, and why the town was named after an Egyptian god of music and dance
  • Why salt, Ibiza's "white gold", was worth more to the island than precious purple dye
  • How the islanders out-negotiated Rome, and how the Moors and then the Catalans reshaped Ibiza
  • Why Ibiza's churches were built like fortresses, and how Dalt Vila's Renaissance walls influenced the defences of places like Havana, San Juan and Cartagena
  • How four very different places add up to five UNESCO criteria, making Ibiza a mixed World Heritage Site
  • What Posidonia seagrass has to do with Ibiza's famously clear water, and what threatens it today
  • Whether Ibiza should really be one mixed site: our debate
  • Travel tips: a two-day heritage itinerary for Puig des Molins, Dalt Vila, Sa Caleta, Ses Salines and Formentera, plus the best time to visit and how to keep costs down

Sources for our research

Show transcript

Ralf: The fortress design on this island has been so effective that the techniques behind it got exported to coastlines thousands of miles away. And Lina, you've actually already stood inside two places based off them without probably ever realizing it.

Lina: Um, now I'm curious, which places are you talking about?

Ralf: Cartagena in Colombia and San Juan in Puerto Rico. Spain perfected the design here to keep pirates out and then exported the same techniques to fortify its colonies. This is Ibiza in Spain and we are the World Heritage Rookies.

Lina: Each episode, we explore together what makes a place special enough to be preserved for future generations.

Ralf: And today, I'm taking you to somewhere I only ever knew as a party island and had absolutely no idea it had UNESCO World Heritage status at all.

Lina: Hi everybody, my name is Lina and welcome to World Heritage Rookies, the podcast where we talk about World Heritage Sites. If you are a new listener, that means you like World Heritage Sites.

Ralf: And if you are a repeated listener, that also means that you like World Heritage Sites. And we thank you so much for coming back to episode 17, which is going to be about Ibiza. I do not know how to pronounce it properly in Spanish — Ibiza, Ibiza — so I'm just going to call it Ibiza during this episode. Sue me.

Lina: In Spanish it's clear, you just say it as you write it, which I will not put as a complaint for many other languages, but what the hell.

Ralf: Okay, so it's going to be Ibiza.

Lina: Ibiza, or with accent, Ibiza.

Ralf: Okay, I'm going to stick with Ibiza, I'm not going to fake a Spanish accent. But yes, we're traveling today to probably one of the biggest party locations in Europe, I would assume, right? If I think about Ibiza, that is probably the first thing that comes into my mind.

Lina: Maybe I'm going to jump a little bit into our first normal section, where you ask, like, Lina, what do you know about Ibiza? But it really surprised me that it was a World Heritage Site. Before we started our adventure, I didn't know. And of course, you just associate it with the party culture of the island. But now I know it's a World Heritage Site. And it's in Spain. And that's it.

Ralf: Yeah, exactly. That was also something very surprising for me, I have to admit. Because, like you, even as a European, I know it mainly as a party island and famous for, like, to have, like, really good DJs and great nightlife. But it is actually a World Heritage Site that has both cultural and natural aspects. Also, a bit of a spoiler ahead of what we are going to discuss in this episode. But, yeah. Apart from that, I mean, you mentioned it already, it's associated with Spain. So, it's a Spanish island, but it's by itself, so it is a Balearic island. So, it's about 90 kilometers from the closest Spanish mainland, as I've found, and about 150 kilometers from Valencia. And it's apparently a lot smaller than I normally would assume. So, I read in some of my sources that, like, you can really drive from the north until to the southern coast in, like, just about an hour with the car.

Lina: So, it's really a small island.

Ralf: Yeah, but, yeah, a lot of activities going on there. It is, as you said, it's really famous for its food, for its party culture. It's, as I learned, also pretty famous as a sort of, like, spiritual retreat. And this is actually going to tie nicely to some of the history I'm going to talk about, because it's quite interesting how it has developed into what it is today.

Lina: So, let's dive in.

Ralf: Yes. So, yeah. Jumping directly into the history and what I found interesting about it. So, talking about, okay, what was, like, the first human occupation or, like, any kind of human footprint on the island. It's assumed that it's dating back to about 3,000 years ago. So, this is then, like, around in the Bronze Age. And there are some evidences that are linked to this. Like, you have some cave paintings at the island. You have some artifacts. And it's mostly assumed that you would have, like, yeah, sailors that arrived there that used this island mainly as a navigational waypoint. And not so much as a permanent home. So, of course, you can never fully exclude it. But it is assumed that it was for a very long time, like, just a stop-and-go place, basically, instead of, like, people living there. Do you have any idea who could be the first people who made it actually, like, a permanent settlement in that area? I mean, talking about the Mediterranean area that it is, in who was active in that time?

Lina: I mean, you say the Bronze Era, right?

Ralf: Yeah. So, that was one of the first things, like, so. But the really, who could you think were the first permanent settlers in this area?

Lina: The Carthaginians?

Ralf: You are absolutely spot-on.

Lina: I am amazing in history. What can I tell you?

Ralf: Well, at least when it comes to Carthaginians, yeah, so, you're absolutely right — so it is linked, the first true recorded history comes into existence with the arrival of the Phoenicians, which would then, like, yeah, later be also called the Punics or the Carthaginians, when Carthage was becoming the main center of their, let's call it, empire.

Lina: Just a small parenthesis here, we are full fans of the Carthaginians.

Ralf: Well, we — I think we are fans of the Carthaginian and Roman conflict in general, because it's a very interesting period.

Lina: We even have a game about it.

Ralf: Yeah, that's, uh...

Lina: And a game that, just another parenthesis, and I'm winning so far.

Ralf: I have the feeling you always get the feeling that you're winning at everything — I will not comment this any further, because I want to avoid any kind of arguments in our married life. But yes, so it is documented that the Phoenicians arrived in the year 654 before common era, and this was then when the first true recorded history of the islands of Ibiza came into record. And the first settlement, or the first permanent settlement established there was called Sa Caleta, which, as I remember, right, it was around the southern tip of the main island around there. And over time, they would actually relocate, let's say, their main settlement to a bit of a more defensible bay, where they founded what is today modern-day Ibiza town. It was founded under the name Ibushim, and it was named after, Bes, which is actually a god, or goddess — I'm not 100% sure — of originally Egyptian origin. And do you have any idea what this might have been the god, or, you know, goddess of?

Lina: Uhm, no, I don't, but just a wild guess — alcohol, beer, something like that?

Ralf: Close enough, I mention it because I find it highly ironic, so, it is, apparently, the Egyptian deity of, well, first, protection — makes sense — but also music and dance. Yeah, so, I do not know if the Carthaginians already had a sort of prediction what Ibiza might become, but I found it, doing my research, super ironic, that one of the most well-known party and club locations in Europe today was originally named after the God of Dance, thousands of years before the whole clubbing boom actually happened.

Lina: It's just one of these history tips and facts that you're like, huh — history writing itself.

Ralf: Um, but yes, so as the empire of Carthage rose — Carthage rose, oh god, difficult words— also Ibiza became more and more important. And it has, during the rule, actually transformed into a heavily fortified commercial powerhouse, so you can imagine, with its location, it was really important also in this.

Ralf: So, they had a lot of wealth there coming from trade with wool, agricultural goods, and also purple dye — so, you know, what they used to make colors, like, clothes colored, and this is, if I remember, it's, like, you need to extract something from snails out of this. So, it was super expensive during antiquity, because it was really hard to get. But, actually, this was, even this was not the main economic income of Ibiza. That was attributed to something else, and to be specific, to the harvesting of the island's natural salt flats. So, Las Salinas, so, as you know, as we know, for example, also from your episode about the Royal Salt Mines in Poland, in ancient times, or, like, even in Middle Ages, like...

Lina: Salt was gold.

Ralf: So, like, the white gold, it became really the economic backbone of the island for centuries. And I think — ka-ching, ka-ching — I think you know for sure, so, if I'm talking about, first now, the Phoenicians or Carthaginians being on the island, who do you think was next on the island?

Lina: The Romans!

Ralf: Oh, so spot-on, um, so, yes, so when the Roman Republic, they finally defeated the Carthaginians — I think, in this case, it was the second Punic War — but they would then absorb the Balearic Islands also into their rule, they absorbed Ibiza, which was then renamed to Ebusus, but apparently the Ibizans played it pretty smart.

Lina: Because it was super different, right?

Ralf: Yes, uh, well, it was Roman then and not Phoenician, so definitely different. But apparently the inhabitants of, uh, now today's Ibiza played it pretty smart, so they negotiated a pretty good deal with the Romans, which basically allowed them to keep most of their Carthaginian traditions, the local governance, and they could even keep their original coins for generations. I assume for the Romans it was like, yeah, we don't want to have too much trouble with this island. As long as you're paying us money, all is good and as long as you are not causing any problems, but apparently they've already showed, like, okay, the people of Ibiza were pretty good at negotiating their way out of the new lords of the island, let's call it like this.

Lina: I mean, as you mentioned it, probably they were really good merchants of salt, so I'm pretty sure they had some experiences before that.

Ralf: I definitely hoped that they had experience in negotiating before, but this is actually a bit of a common theme in the coming centuries — because Ibiza actually changed ownership, or that's the wrong word to say, but I mean, Ibiza was, over the following centuries, influenced by a lot of different cultures. So, after you had the collapse of Rome, the island, as many parts of Europe, suffered brutal raids by various, especially Germanic raids — there were raids by the Vandals in the year 426 common era.

Lina: Too soon to say Germans making problems forever.

Ralf: Yeah, perhaps too soon to say, and perhaps also not politically correct, but in this case, yeah, it was the Vandals that, in the year 426, they were raiding the islands. And then there followed a time when it was under Byzantine rule, actually, which led to more stabilization, and also other important things, like, for example, crucial sharecropping, which helped the whole landscaping, or agricultural part there, and different irrigation techniques. We're jumping then even further, so we're coming to the area of the Islamic Renaissance, from the year 902 to 1235 common era. So, again, another renaming — it was then called Yebiza. I know, also very different.

Lina: I love how they just changed a couple letters to put it to their own culture, and that's it. Not really a change of name, but it really makes sense, because if you think about the population that was living there, can you imagine every certain century had to change their name just because of the new ruler? And I'm pretty sure in these times, like, people were probably used to these kind of changes, and they were like, uh, just whatever.

Ralf: I do not know if they were used to these changes, because there are still centuries between.

Lina: But, anyway, history repeats itself, and I'm pretty sure they knew about these kind of changes.

Ralf: The pattern is definitely interesting, and what I also found very interesting is that, like, during Muslim rule, it's really accounted for that the island really flourished. So, sort of what has started, as I understood with the Byzantine rule, is, like, really local agriculture was revolutionized during the Islamic Renaissance. So, the ruling Moors, they engineered the so-called Ses Feixes, if I pronounce that correctly, which is apparently a really sophisticated way to make wetland irrigation systems around there. And if you know also the climate around Ibiza, that was really crucial also to ensure just that you would have a good yield in the whole agriculture. And this led then to another boom sort of economy — horticulture, fishing, and also even more expansion of the salt production would really lead to Ibiza becoming economically strong, similar to, like, previous times, as I understood during the Islamic rule.

Lina: So, is this period considered, like, the golden age of Ibiza?

Ralf: I do not know if you would consider it by itself the golden age. Probably depends who you are asking it. But it is definitely important to highlight that, if you look at the macro perspective, at least from what I found in the sources during my research, that the Muslim rule in Ibiza was generally considered a good economic time for the place, yes.

Lina: Understood.

Ralf: Well, as usual, in the history of the island, things changed. So, in the year 1235 common era — specifically on August the 8th, so just in case one of my close friends from high school is listening, yes, that happened on your birthday — at that day, the Crown of Aragon under Jaume I, I think is it pronounced, seized the island, so it's the Christian Reconquista. And that led then again to a total shift to demographic and cultural factors. So, you would have settlers from the Catalan area replacing the Moorish population, the main mosque of the island was torn down to build a cathedral, and the whole geography of the island was apparently aggressively rebranded with the names of Christian saints. So, as soon as the Christians got to Ibiza, they were like, okay, we're gonna make sure everybody knows that this island is again under Christian rule.

Lina: It is so interesting, because it happens not only in Christianism, but in other religions, where, like, one takes over the other one, and it's this branding, right? Like, it is like, we need to erase what happened before, like, never existed. But it's just a constant, and I think that in certain terms, it makes sense. Otherwise, accepting the change of, like, religion so suddenly can be problematic.

Ralf: Yeah, it is, first, as you said, it's a statement — okay, this is now, again, Christian — but also, as you said, it's a way to really emphasize, okay, like, we are the rulers right now, and there are multiple ways to do this. And I think they did it, like, par excellence, or, in lack of a better term, was the replacement of the population, because if you replace it with largely Christian population, then you're not risking uprising by the local Muslim. Which is horrible by itself, that you are, sort of, chasing out people who have lived there for centuries, but if you are a new conqueror of this kind of place, especially with religious differences, it sort of makes sense if you want to ensure that it's stable, unfortunately.

Lina: Yeah, from a political point of view, for sure, but, of course, it is always controversial.

Ralf: Yeah, from an ethical or, like, a moral point of view, it is a really... that's another conversation, yeah. Yes, and then, obviously, the following centuries, this also was impacting the history of Ibiza.

Ralf: What else has been impacting this is that, from the 16th to the 18th century, Ibiza apparently lived under, like, really constant threat of North African pirate raids. So, this is something that has influenced, really, the shape and how the island looks until today. Because the sheer need for survival against all of these pirate raids that would come around there, they led to the creation of a really unique architectural landscape in Ibiza. So, first, you have something which I think was common sense, like, you would have really a ring of lookout towers around the whole coastal area, just to say, okay, hey, there are pirates coming, let's get to safety. But what I found really interesting is also, they have really adopted this in the way they are building their churches. So, the churches of Ibiza were, for a very long time, built like real fortresses. So, they had massive, windowless, thick stone walls, and really were supposed to serve more as sort of military bunkers, where villagers in the rural population of Ibiza could take shelter and lock themselves inside during pirate sieges. And I do not know if I have encountered any kind of place where, like, all of the churches were, for a long time, built as sort of bunkers or fortresses.

Lina: I found that really interesting because there were, during these times, other zones of, like, conflict. And I think that not many places actually adopted this double architecture, you know? Like, where, okay, yes, it has a religious purpose as the first main purpose, but, okay, let's use this building for something else in case of. This is, in some cases, true, and today this happens a lot, for instance, with subway stations, where they also function, in many cases, as bunkers. But churches, now I'm really interested — I think that I have not seen any, but there are still some standing?

Ralf: As I understand, some of the main cathedrals are still standing, yes.

Lina: That would be super interesting to see because, yeah, it is true that it's, I mean, it's a public space that can be really easily accessible for many people in case of conflict.

Ralf: And it had even more impact, because one of the main parts of Ibiza that are also today a World Heritage Site — so again, spoiling a little bit — was influenced by this. So King Philip II, in order to combat these constant threats from outside, he commissioned the construction of the massive walls that are, until today, seen in the upper town, which is called Dalt Vila. And these sort of arrow-shaped, heptagonal bastions, they were, at this time, considered cutting-edge military technology, and actually, this very specific combination of Italian-Spanish fortification style, it was so successful that it became the exact blueprint that was then exported to the New World, heavily influencing the defenses of cities like Havana, San Juan. I think I read in one of the sources that also the walls in Cartagena, Colombia, were influenced by this. So, in a way, you could see that the Renaissance fortification walls of Ibiza are, like, for a lot of areas, the blueprint of the fortifications you would have today in the Americas also.

Lina: That's so interesting, especially because, of course, I had been in Cartagena several times, and then I visited Puerto Rico, and the fortress in San Juan looked exactly like Cartagena's. I mean, of course, some changes in the structure, especially because it has, like, a pointing view, but they look quite similar, and I was like, oh, okay, one had to copy the other one. Well, now I know that both of them were copying Ibiza's. How interesting.

Ralf: Yeah, that's true. And, yes, this leads us a little bit towards the more modern history of Ibiza. So, by the 18th and 19th centuries, Ibiza lost much of its autonomy that it had for such a long time, and it was also then slipping more and more into economic depression, so it was for a very long time that the population returned more to a bit of a quiet, isolated, agrarian lifestyle. The revival, sort of what helped Ibiza shape into what it is today, was in the 1930s. So, because in the 1930s, I assume, people were probably influenced by a lot of what happened in Europe during these periods, you saw that a lot of artists and writers had to escape to the island, to, well, I assume mostly from fascism, that, unfortunately, was rising, as we know, with Franco and everything else in Spain, much earlier than in some other places compared to Europe. And so a lot of, yeah, more avant-garde artists and writers, they had to escape to Ibiza to find really sort of a sanctuary, and this has been shaping Ibiza for the coming decades as well. And by the 1960s, the island has really transformed into a vital stop on the global hippie trail. So, it was really a source, or a beacon of spiritual freedom, musical experimentation and artistical expression. And this was attributed as one of the main reasons why it has become today such a massive touristic and electronic dance music — I think it's especially what's famous around there — by the 1970s and 80s until today. So, really connecting sort of the dots. Obviously, history is not just progressing from, okay, then this happened and that happened, but when you see the long-term involvement — okay, first as a escape spot, let's say, against fascism, then, leading to, and until today, it is considered, yeah, next to music, like, it's really a spiritual place, so you can find a lot of offers there, as I read, that are following, like, just the whole spiritual topics and...

Lina: Retreats and so on.

Ralf: Retreats and everything. So, that has shaped the history of Ibiza until today.

Lina: That's a reminder that in history never — it never happens, like, oh, an island, oh, let's put bars here and clubs. No, that's not how it actually happens.

Ralf: Yeah, normally they put jails on islands.

Lina: Yeah, this one is a little bit different. Not yet, not yet. I hope they don't put jails... Does Ibiza have a jail, though?

Ralf: I do not know. We would have to research this, but I would assume there are no places for jails next to all the nightclubs.

Lina: I mean, that's where they should be, probably.

Ralf: Most of us — I mean, you can pitch this idea to the government from Ibiza, but actually, this is a good transition for the next segment, because...

Lina: Transition!

Ralf: Because the government of Ibiza, as I understand, has also worked really hard in the past years that Ibiza is not only known as this party location, but also for its, well, cultural and historical — as we learned just now, there is a lot of history going on for Ibiza. And that is now bringing me the question to you: as usual, how many criteria as a UNESCO World Heritage Site do you think fulfills Ibiza?

Lina: More than five.

Ralf: No.

Lina: No, it's a mix. So, both natural and historical. And I feel that I am spoiling it.

Ralf: A little bit. So, it is fitting five criteria, because it is indeed a mixed World Heritage Site.

Lina: But I said five!

Ralf: You said more than five! So, like, you know, it's meeting five, yeah, because it's a mixed World Heritage Site. So, I think the official name is Ibiza, Biodiversity and Culture — or Culture and Biodiversity, I'm not 100% sure — but that's how it's officially recognized within UNESCO. And there are actually four distinct locations that are making it this kind of mixed World Heritage Site. One I already mentioned, which is the upper town, Dalt Vila, which is, yeah, still until today considered, like, a prime example of a fortified Acropolis. So you have these 16th century Renaissance walls, the maze inside of it, like all of the cobblestone streets, with the cathedral, the Almudaina Castle, and really, let's say, traces of the Phoenician, Arab, and Catalonian civilizations around there. And this is actually fulfilling two criteria. So the first one is criteria two, which is about cultural exchange and influence — because it is still so intact and well preserved, and it has been inspiring the fortifications in the New World, as I explained before. And criteria four is, as a prime historic example, because it is a really pristine example of a fortified 16th century Acropolis. Then, what do you think could be the other locations that you find in the islands that are, especially, from a cultural perspective?

Lina: Um, something Roman.

Ralf: Even earlier, you will find actually remains from the Phoenician Carthaginians.

Lina: We need to go to Ibiza.

Ralf: Yeah, I think we need some money to save before that, but yeah, so you have actually two remains from the Phoenician time. The first is called — uh, god, I'm gonna butcher this — the Puig des Molins Necropolis, which is really next to the old town of Ibiza. And this is considered the largest and best preserved Carthaginian cemetery in the whole Western Mediterranean. So, it is holding up to 5,000 ancient graves. The excavations that were done there led to the discovery of Egyptian-style amulets, terracotta figures, painted ostrich eggs, which was, for me — I mean, I've never seen a painted ostrich egg, but...

Lina: Painted ostrich eggs!

Ralf: Amazing!

Lina: From 3,000 years ago!

Ralf: Uh-huh. Yeah. I'm not sure if they are that old, but I mean, like, definitely they are old. And all of these artifacts and all of the graves, they're really proving that Ibiza was, at this time, like, a really cosmopolitan, globalized trading hub, because, I mean, Egypt is not that close to the Balearic Islands. So, this is then really showing the importance that it has as a trading city, or as a trading hub, for the Phoenicians. But, actually, you still sort of can find the remains of, let's call it, the ground zero of history on Ibiza, because you can actually still find remains of the original Phoenician settlement that I mentioned before, Sa Caleta. It is a bit further away towards the southern part of the main island, and, yeah, the ruins, they are, as I mentioned before, dated towards the 8th century before the Common Era, and this is generally considered the island's first permanent colony. And it was abandoned peacefully when the original Phoenician settlers moved to Ibiza town, or however it was called during the Phoenicians, and you can still, until today, see the remaining stone footprints and the foundations that really give a bit of a glimpse into how the early life was for the Phoenicians.

Lina: I guess you can still visit that site?

Ralf: You can see it because, as I saw from my research, everything is surrounded by a fence, so you cannot actually — it's not that much anymore, so you see really just the foundations and the bases. So, from a pure, let's say aesthetic value, it is not that spectacular, but obviously the historical importance cannot be denied. But, so, those two things — the necropolis and the remains from Sa Caleta — they are fulfilling criterion number three, which is like a unique cultural testimony, so they both serve as an evidence of urbanization and life in the Phoenician colonies.

Lina: That's so interesting, because normally, I mean, there is evidence of existence of previous civilizations, but now, here, you know exactly where they started.

Ralf: Exactly, yeah. And that leads us, then, to the natural part, because, as you mentioned, coming from what the current theme is of our episodes we're discussing at the moment.

Lina: Which is still, I guess, by this point, still surprise?

Ralf: Well, surprise in quotation marks, but I think regular listeners have figured out by now. But this leads us to the natural part of it, which is the cause for it being a mixed-World Heritage Site, and something that I have not mentioned yet so far. This is related to Posidonia oceanica. Any idea what that could be?

Lina: Posidonia oceanica. Well, it's an animal, or a plant, that has to do something with the ocean?

Ralf: True. Um, it's seagrass.

Lina: Seagrass?

Ralf: Yes. So, you can find this primarily between, like, yeah, Ibiza and the smaller island south of Ibiza, which is called Formentera. This is an endemic Mediterranean marine plant, which really forms underwater forests of seagrass. And what is really fascinating about it is that some colonies of this seagrass are estimated to be over 100,000 years old, which would make them one of the oldest living organisms on Earth still in existence today. And why they are so relevant — the seagrass is really responsible for putting oxygen into the water, providing a lot of shelter, and sort of like a nursery, breeding places for the local marine life. And it is also physically buffering the coastline of the islands to prevent beach erosion. And this seagrass is actually considered one of the main reasons why the waters around Ibiza are so famously crystal clear today.

Lina: So, thanks to the grass, that they are so beautiful.

Ralf: Yes. So, this Posidonia oceanica, which is a seagrass — this is then actually fulfilling two natural criteria. So, first, criteria number nine, which is the living nature and a unique ecosystem, because this seagrass, together with the coral reefs that you also find in the shorelines near Ibiza, is creating a very unique ecosystem. And, as I mentioned before, the seagrass forests, as they call them, are supporting really a diverse maritime life, both flora and fauna, and this is meeting criteria number ten, which is the wildlife protection. And those five criteria, together, are what making Ibiza today a World Heritage Site.

Lina: Which is really interesting, right? Because, of course, now we know the history is quite important, but it's this combination between — hey, Ibiza has a long historical past, also is well known for its culture and how it developed, from the 20th century. And now it's also, I mean, it has a life that cannot be found anywhere else.

Ralf: Yes, that's something I think you would not normally associate with Ibiza, but what I found also interesting during my research, that especially sort of in the community of World Heritage Travellers, I saw really some — well, complaints is the wrong term, but there were some voices who were saying it's a bit weird. Because, is it really necessary that it was a mixed World Heritage Site? Because, on the one hand, you have Phoenician remains, then you have the Renaissance fortifications from Dalt Vila, and then you have, sort of, underwater forests made out of seagrass. So, that leads us a bit to the discussion for today. That's a very weird combination. So — did they make it themselves a bit too easy around there, just like, yeah, okay, let's just make it a mixed World Heritage Site, it has this, it has that, it has this — because they have, by itself, no really physical or also direct narrative connections, because especially the seagrass meadows, they're a bit further south, and this is sort of a bit of, I would say, the criticism that you find around this site, that the four elements that make this World Heritage Site, they're not really connected. What's your take on that — do you think they should have perhaps been, like, separate World Heritage Sites, or does it make sense that they are all four together?

Lina: I mean, it is true that it seems like you just put really specific things that the island had to offer, get it in a pod, and mix it, and put it out to the UNESCO World Heritage community — well, entity. But at the same time, I mean, it really is what you want to say, or what you want to show to the world, a UNESCO World Heritage Site. In my perspective, as an island, I would not expect an island that can be, like, completely discovered in one hour to have three World Heritage Sites, let's say to say. And it's also really unlikely that UNESCO will accept something like that. We really have to remember that World Heritage Sites become a World Heritage Site because they are unique or specific in certain ways. So, I guess that this, putting all of these factors together, which, yeah, they are pretty much unrelated, kind of made the island become a World Heritage Site. As a separate entity, I don't know if the seagrass will be enough. Maybe the main town, yes, but it will not be as impressive, because what happens if you have more things to show, but because they are not a World Heritage Site, people probably will not know about them. So, I would say, because it's an island, and it's really hard for an island to become a World Heritage Site just because it's pretty, or has, maybe, historical importance. Though there are many other places that had historical importance — maybe it was not enough. So, in this case, it had to be like that, though we will have to see how it was presented to the UNESCO entity itself.

Ralf: I think you make a very good point there, in the fact that, yeah, what is, sort of, the intention behind this? And, obviously, here it is, for me, considered — well, what is the entirety of Ibiza, what makes it so special to become a World Heritage Site? And this is then, like, well, these supposedly, at the first place, unrelated areas or elements of the islands — well, when you put them together, they are showing why Ibiza is worth to be a World Heritage Site. Because it's the whole history of the thing. You have the elements that were long there before human nature, with the seagrass, and you had the elements that shaped the history, as we heard before, that was so turbulent and had so many different changes. And I actually think that having the integration of the somewhat unrelated Phoenician remains, and at the same time also the Renaissance fortifications of their old town, that's actually very good-fitting the, let's say, personality of Ibiza, which is really historic. There were so many different cultures influencing the island over the centuries, then of course you would have, like, unrelated elements form together its World Heritage status.

Lina: I mean, in the end of the day, we come back to the conversation we had a couple episodes ago. It's like, for me, for instance, some sites have too many World Heritage — or, like, especially the mixed ones. For me, the idea is still a controversial topic, because sometimes I feel like it's really interesting, but sometimes I feel like UNESCO is really good at giving a specific criteria to some of the sites, but sometimes I feel like they are too generous. But in this case, I think that it makes sense. It makes sense in the sense that, look, it's because of the seagrass that the beaches, which are really well-known in Ibiza, are as they are. So, in this case, I would say, actually, it kind of makes sense, in my perspective, of course.

Ralf: Yeah, I mean, let us know, as your listeners, if you think, okay, does it make sense to have a mixed World Heritage Site or not? We would love to hear from you.

Lina: Also, I mean, think about the other episodes — you guys know, for our listeners that are, well, recurrent listeners, let's say to say, that there are many amazing sites that had only one or two criteria. So now we're talking about the ones that have a lot, and it would be really interesting to see from your side what is your perspective about these World Heritage Sites that had a lot of criteria, and they are mixed criteria.

Ralf: Indeed.

Ralf: I think one thing I want to mention before jumping over to the segment with the travel tips is, as we know, it has also a natural element to it, so that means there is some concern about the conservation, and this is where I will reference the IUCN outlook. So, for anyone not familiar with this — the IUCN, it monitors the health of natural World Heritage Sites, and you will find a link to this monitoring, or the assessment of the IUCN, in the show notes. And currently, unfortunately, the outlook for Ibiza is listed as significant concern, meaning that the ecosystem around the island faces really severe and over-the-time compounding threats. I guess you have an idea what could be some of those threats, yeah?

Lina: They have too many snakes, and that's not good, because they are not endemic to the island, and I just recently knew that, and let me tell you, I'm super frightened of snakes, so when I got to know that, I was like, maybe I cannot go to Ibiza.

Ralf: And that is actually your one — that is actually your one reason of the concerns, you're absolutely true. So, invasive species — so, on the first side, you have algae that are, well, competing with the seagrass underwater, and also invasive mainland species, especially snakes, which are threatening local fauna on land.

Lina: Yeah, I know, it's a no-no for me. I was like — and the worst part is that they were brought, I mean, historically, there were many reasons why they're on this island, because I did research, because I was like, oh, there is snakes on Ibiza, of course I cannot go. But one of the reasons is because many of the new inhabitants, let's say to say, the people that moved recently, in recent years, they wanted to bring olive oil trees, and olive oil trees include a lot of eggs of snakes, and I was like, no, no, why did you do that? No more snakes.

Ralf: I did not know that, so you're schooling me in my own research episode.

Lina: Just to say that, yeah, honestly, that's the only thing I know about Ibiza, and it's because I am so frightened of snakes, and I was like, no! And the worst part is that, apparently, it's so bad, the situation right now, because I was reading some news online, is that sometimes you walk through the street and you see snakes just eating rats, and I'm like, nope! That's a no-no for me.

Ralf: So, yeah, that is one thing, but what you also have to consider, unfortunately, is the whole mass tourism and the yachts that it brought with it — just the sheer volume of boats you have around there, and sometimes, or most of the times, apparently, unregulated boat traffic is really tearing up the underwater forests of the seagrass. And the problem with the seagrass is also, it's pretty slow-growing, so it can take a really long time that it's recovering. I read that when you have a bigger patch that is being destroyed, it can take centuries to recover, so this is one aspect that is unfortunately affecting it. And, as with a lot of other natural World Heritage Sites — climate change. Especially the rising temperatures in the Mediterranean Sea are triggering heat waves around the waters there that, apparently, literally cook the seagrass and are affecting this unique ecosystem. And this is, I think, also a very good — like, you have a bit of a paradox there, because Ibiza is generally considered, obviously, a pretty wealthy island, I would assume, because its tourism is really funding a lot of wealth there, and this wealth, on the one hand, is necessary to fund the conservation, but also just the sheer volume of tourists is destroying the natural assets of the island. And that also shows, again, the balance you need to find, for a lot of World Heritage Sites, between overtourism and making sure that what is so valuable about the island is protected. And, at the moment, it seems like the whole influx of tourists coming to Ibiza, it's hard to control for the management of the conservation.

Lina: We come back to this paradox between what a World Heritage Site — what the title can bring to a specific site — and what are the consequences. And maybe, really, we need to go in-depth in a future episode about this, but the fact is, it's almost the same scenario in many World Heritage Sites. Most of them, I would say.

Ralf: It can be a blessing and a curse, even though I would say Ibiza is special in a way — I do not think it was mainly affected by its UNESCO World Heritage status,

Lina: No, it had a culture before.

Ralf: Because it is — yeah, it is not, it is less known for being a World Heritage Site than it's known for, it's like, really, party and food and everything else. So, I would say you cannot blame, in quotation marks, the World Heritage title for the overtourism, but it is, of course, something that you have to be able to balance.

Lina: Yeah. Exactly. So, again, conscious traveling is always necessary, and always have it in your mind — especially if you go to these places that are so strained by the amount of tourism.

Ralf: True, yeah.

Ralf: And that's a good transition actually into our last segment,

Lina: Transition!

Ralf: The travel guide. So, just as a quick disclaimer — we will not go into any details here about what this island is mostly known for. So, if you're looking for any kind of recommendations for clubbing, beaches, and anything else, there are a lot of other podcasts, YouTube videos, or blogs out there where you will find information, we will focus on what you need to take into consideration if you want to experience the World Heritage Site of Ibiza. So, I'm starting a little bit with recommendations about the itinerary. If you really just want to experience the World Heritage aspect of Ibiza, two days would be enough. If you're really rushing through it, you can probably see everything in one day, but to give it a little bit of patience, and also the time it deserves, it's normally said, okay, give it two days. So the first day is, say, you combine the necropolis and the old town. Normally it's recommended you should start with the Puig des Molins necropolis. The admission for this is normally around €2.50. In my current research, I saw that, at the moment, it's in general free admission, but I think this is only going to be temporary, so whenever you're going to listen to this, check it out again — apparently it's generally free to go there on Sundays. And what is normally advised is that there is a museum where you can see some of the artifacts and the excavations that were done. You can also descend into the subterranean burial chambers themselves, which are called Hypogea. And what I found there, sort of as a little tip, is that when you are going to these burial chambers, you should look for some holes in the walls of these chambers, because these were smashed through by ancient and medieval tomb raiders that were looking for treasure, and they're sort of like a bit of a fascinating piece of meta history, because you are going now into those tombs, hopefully without the intent of stealing something. And you see — and now you're looking at the holes that were created by other people who were trying to get in there, but probably not to visit it as World Heritage travelers.

Lina: The sidequest, let's say, today.

Ralf: Yeah. And this is like how you can spend the early morning until noon. And then, for the afternoon, you can spend some time to walk over the old town of Dalt Vila. You should plan about two to three hours walking through it in a leisurely way, so you can really experience around there. It is a really easy place to walk through — the streets are well maintained, you have a lot of cafes and restaurants also in the old town, if you need to have some kind of break, especially with the heat around it. And what also has been sort of recommended here is that you should try to catch some historical reenactments that especially take place at dusk — they are organized by the city council, and they're apparently supposed to bring the medieval lifestyle, or the renaissance lifestyle, a bit more to life, so you can experience it a little bit better. Otherwise, obviously, you can also just walk through the old town and experience the beauty of it by yourself. That is, I would say, the main part, and also, what we have to admit, probably the most visually stunning aspect of Ibiza.

Ralf: On a second day, you can then also explore more the coastal areas. It is generally advised that you should try to rent a scooter or a car there, because especially buses around there, to remote areas, they are not so reliable, especially on weekends. And there you can then visit, as I mentioned before, the ruins of Sa Caleta. Don't be too disappointed if you cannot see that much, because, yeah, it is surrounded by a fence to protect the site.

Lina: We say, yeah, it's just the bases. It's not the first time we've seen a site and people get really disappointed, but we're being honest here.

Ralf: Yes. And in the afternoon, you can, if you want, visit the meadow area — you can either take a ferry to Formentera, or you can visit the Ses Salines Nature Reserve, and also beaches like Es Cavallet, they showcase really this dune system that is preserved entirely by the underwater seagrass. And there is also very often recommended that this is the more stunning natural place, so you can rent a bike and ride all around the green. Especially, as I understood, Formentera is very pretty with regard to visiting and just enjoying the nature around there, which, yeah, a lot of people that are also not just interested in World Heritage Sites enjoy just because of the beautiful landscape. And, yes, just a little bit further — as you can imagine, Ibiza gets really busy, especially during peak seasons. So, if you are not interested in the whole beach experience, the dancing and the clubbing and everything else, you could consider going more towards the period of April to June or September to October — this is generally considered, like, the best weather-to-crowd ratio, let's call it like this, because, especially during the summer months, Ibiza is packed with tourists. And, obviously, to consider — it's not gonna be a cheap experience. Ibiza is considered a very expensive location, even for European standards.

Lina: Ka-ching!

Ralf: Ka-ching. But, also, to try to keep a bit under budget — like, okay, do not eat in restaurants, instead pack some picnic or so for you. Alongside, this is something you should also consider. Just saying, you will probably not be going to Ibiza just for the World Heritage aspect, but if you're staying longer, and everything there, yeah, be aware — make your budget calculations, be aware that it's expensive and costly. But if you're going, I'm quite sure you can experience quite an amazing and unexpected side of Ibiza, just set aside from all of the main party-drive things. Yes, that's what I wanted to share about Ibiza, Biodiversity and Culture.

Ralf: What's your verdict, Lina? You want to go?

Lina: I really want to go, but I will wait a little bit to see if they do something about the snakes. Haha! No, just joking. Joking aside, I think that is an amazing place, and I'm really happy to see that it's more than just a party island. But, of course, you can enjoy both — that's the interesting and fun part about this site. You can be in the morning and in the afternoon in the historical part, and enjoy a little bit the party, the club. Just being conscious — try to be rational about your decisions and how you interact with the environment, and especially the nature of the island. And if you can, donate to any specific place that is supporting taking care of the environment of the island — I think that this is also something that you could do if you really want to visit. And, yeah, I mean, I will be happy to go, but, again, I will wait a little bit.

Ralf: Okay, assuming the island is snake-free enough for you, like Lina, visiting Ibiza will be okay during the day — we're gonna see some World Heritage, and in the night, we're gonna go clubbing.

Lina: I mean, that sounds amazing. Though I do have to admit, we are in our Thirties, so...

Ralf: We are old now, I mean...

Lina: Yeah,

Ralf: I don't know, like, we're probably gonna be more like — yeah, we're gonna go clubbing and we're gonna fall asleep by 10pm.

Lina: For sure, maybe this is exactly one of the pieces that Ibiza needs, and it's one of these clubs that I'd like to be closing until 10pm. I guess this is like a parent's club, which I absolutely am on. Yeah, no, you know, we need a lot of time in advance, in preparation, to go clubbing today. I think that would not change tomorrow, and if we got to see the historical parts during the day, maybe we need an extra day just to relax, and then we go clubbing. But if this is something you like, this is definitely a place you should visit.

Ralf: Actually, I found a recommendation — if you want to experience sort of the clubbing scene of Ibiza but still, well, go to bed, you should try to actually hit some beach clubs, because they will typically start earlier, and very often you're able to already experience sort of the vibe of Ibiza without having to go to one of the nightclubs where you have to stay up late. So, if, yeah, just saying, perhaps this would be something we have to check out.

Lina: Are we becoming a podcast for old people, so, like, just a tip for you to enjoy out, and be in bed by 10.

Ralf: I don't know. If we can, we can see, we want to shift to it, but until then, let's stick with World Heritage Sites, I would suggest. And, perhaps, yeah, this is also a good way you can give us a glimpse — so, on the next episode, you're gonna talk about a World Heritage, I assume, and not about some kind of party club, right?

Lina: I mean, you don't know — no, actually, we are staying in the Mediterranean, so it's gonna be really interesting, because it's also a really beautiful place, but we are staying in Europe.

Ralf: Nice, I'm looking forward to it. Until then, thank you everyone for listening, and see you hopefully next episode.

Lina: Goodbye!

Ralf: Bye-bye!