Mount Athos: The Holy Mountain Women Can't Enter
Inside Greece's 1,000-Year-Old Monastic State
Show notes
Mount Athos isn't just a mountain with a few monasteries on it. It's a self-governing monastic state inside Greece, where the calendar runs 13 days behind the rest of the world, the clocks strike twelve at sunset, and a charter signed in red imperial ink more than a thousand years ago still sets the rules. Cats are welcome. Women are not.
That makes this one personal: Lina researched a place she will never be allowed to enter. It also brings back a question Ralf raised in our Mesa Verde episode — who gets to experience World Heritage? Here, though, the very thing that keeps people out is part of what makes the site special. Add stories about the Virgin Mary, a monk said to have never seen a woman his whole life, and the first site on our show to meet six UNESCO criteria, and you get an episode we're still arguing about.
Corrections & Clarifications
We're rookies, so we like to keep ourselves honest — a few things from this episode worth clarifying:
Are there really hens on Athos? We said it boldly in the cold open, and we're sticking with it, but in fairness: sources disagree on this one! The avaton bans female domestic animals, and cats are the well-known exception for keeping the mice down. Some sources say hens are kept for eggs. Others say there are no chickens on the Mount and eggs are brought in from outside. Either way, the part of the egg used in icon painting is the yolk, not the shell or the white. It binds the pigment in egg tempera.
When was the Hesychast movement? We said "after the 15th century." It was the 14th century. Gregory Palamas championed Hesychasm, and the great controversy over it was settled at councils in Constantinople between 1341 and 1351.
When did Athos become part of Greece? Greece won its independence in the 1820s, but Athos stayed under Ottoman rule until 1912, when the Greek Navy took it during the First Balkan War. Its self-governing status was then confirmed in 1926.
Where do you collect your permit? You reserve your diamonitirion through the Pilgrims' Office in Thessaloniki (by phone or email), but you collect it in person at the Pilgrims' Office in Ouranoupoli on the morning you sail, with your ID or passport (or in Ierissos, for boats to the east coast). It can't be collected in Thessaloniki.
Why do the boats keep their distance? It's a rule, not just the cliffs: boats carrying women must stay at least 500 metres offshore.
What will you learn in this episode?
- How a giant, a rock and Poseidon gave Mount Athos its name
- Why the Virgin Mary is said to have claimed the peninsula as her garden
- Why a charter written on goatskin in 972, the Tragos, still shapes how Athos is governed today
- How the monks survived the Fourth Crusade, Catalan raiders and heavy Ottoman taxes
- Why only 20 ruling monasteries stand today
- Why women, beardless youths and most female animals have been kept out for more than a thousand years
- Stories about an empress carried in a litter and the monk said to have never seen a woman
- How life on Athos still runs on Byzantine rhythms with clocks that strike twelve at sunset and a meat-free diet
- Whether the ban on women should be lifted: a debate that gets personal for Lina
- How Mount Athos became the first site on our show to meet six UNESCO criteria
- Travel tips from the diamonitirion permit, monastery rules, the hike to the 2,033 m summit, and how women can see Athos from the water
Sources for our research
- Official UNESCO Mount Athos Page
- Community for World Heritage Travellers — Mount Athos
- Wikipedia — Mount Athos
- Wikipedia — Monastic Community of Mount Athos
- Britannica — Mount Athos
- EBSCO Research Starters — Mount Athos Monasteries
- Halkidiki Tourism Organization — UNESCO: Mount Athos
- Mount Athos Infos — History
- Visit Mount Athos — History
- Macedonian Heritage — History of Mount Athos
- Mount Athos: Legends, History, and the Secrets of the Monastic Republic (Pilgrimaps)
- Mount Athos: A Timeless Beacon of Orthodox Spirituality (Mount Athos: A Pilgrim's Guide)
- Important Facts about Mount Athos — FAQ for Agion Oros (Monastiriaka)
- Pilgrimage to Mount Athos (Athos Guide)
If you enjoyed this episode, follow us on Instagram at @worldheritagerookies for visuals, fun facts, and hints about our next destinations.
Have questions or your own Mount Athos stories? Send us a message — we'd love to hear from you! Don't forget to follow or subscribe to the podcast so you never miss an episode. Next episode, Ralf takes us to an island — a full island this time, not just a peninsula — and we're staying in Europe. Four sites into our second season, have you figured out what they all have in common yet? Any guesses where we're going?
Show transcript
Lina: For more than a thousand years, no woman has been allowed to set foot on this peninsula, not even most female animals.
Ralf: Most? Some of them got an exemption or like a special invitation?
Lina: Cats. Somebody had to deal with the mice. And hens, because the monks needed the eggs. This is Mount Athos in northern Greece and we are the World Heritage Rookies.
Ralf: Each episode we explore together what makes a place special enough to be preserved for future generations.
Lina: And today I'm taking you to a place I will never be allowed to enter.
Ralf: Hello and welcome everybody to episode 16 of World Heritage Rookies, the podcast where we talk about World Heritage Sites. My name is Ralf, and if you have listened to previous episodes of us, happy to have you back.
Lina: And my name is Lina, and if you are new here, I hope this podcast is interesting for you and you get new information.
Ralf: Yeah, especially for this episode, I'm quite looking forward because I'm going in with no idea what we're gonna talk about. Well, what we're gonna talk about, I know, but like, I have no idea about the details, so what are you gonna present today, Lina?
Lina: Today is gonna be Mount Athos. So, as always, we can maybe go into the topic right away. Do you know anything about Mount Athos?
Ralf: Well, I know the theme it has. Because, as you all know, we try to present, like always, World Heritage Sites that are somehow connected. So, I know a little bit about the criteria it meets, which we're gonna talk about later. I know it's in Greece, and I assume from the name, that's a mountain.
Lina: Indeed, so, it is a mountain. Mount Athos.
Ralf: Okay, good. So, then, anything else that I would need to know?
Lina: No, pretty much it. Thank you so much. It was a great episode. No, out of the joke. So, now the history part. Well, something you need to understand, and I think that I already spoiled, is that the whole Mount Athos, it's actually there because of its religious connotation. It's a holy mountain. The origins are a little bit mixed between mythology and actually faith. So, it is really not historically accurate. We are really not really sure how everybody started to live in this place. What we know is that some myths said that it has — I mean, the history has a really complex political and religious shift, depending to who is telling the story, pretty much. According to ancient Greek lore, you know, this is something that in Greece they have a lot. The mountain.
Ralf: Yeah, I mean, nobody knows about Greek mythology.
Lina: Exactly. They go really deep into mythology, but basically, they say that the mount was created during the battle of the gods and giants, when the giant Athos — that's the name of the mount — basically threw a massive rock at Poseidon. And the rock stayed there, and that's what we call Mount Athos today. During a lot of years, there is not really, like, a real historical connotation or direct line of what happened during the first centuries, but by the fifth century BCE, the Persian king — Xerxes I — famously cut a 1.5-mile canal across the peninsula to avoid really difficult waters to trace through the land. During this era, the peninsula was home to several Greek cities. Nevertheless, they actually left — they deserted Mount Athos — way before it started its religious connotations. So, exactly why and to where these Greek people went, it's not clear.
Lina: Then, this was — again, by the 5th century BCE, by the 4th century BCE, no, sorry, 4th century CE, after Jesus Christ — uh, it's when the arrival of, actually, Christianity started in this peninsula. Monks likely started to arrive by the 4th century, but there was a lot of time of isolation during this period, so it is not really clear when. What is clear is that it really started to increase by the Islamic conquest of Egypt in the 7th century, after Christ. Then, it's when there is a little bit of a religious story about how — so, they say that the monks started to come here because of the story of the Garden of the Virgin, where they claim that the Virgin Mary was blown off course to the Port of Clement, which today is in Iviron in Greece, which is on the left side of the peninsula, so a little bit far away of where the peninsula is today. And when she was blown away, she asked her son, Jesus, to actually give her this land. So, of course, a lot of religious people that wanted to be in complete closure to the world, they started to travel there. By the 9th century, it was famous for monks — the most famous is actually Peter the Athonite, who lived in a cave for 35 years in this mount. By the 9th century, Emperor Basil I issued a decree — actually officially decreed the first place completely dedicated to monks and to pray. That was the first, really the beginning of this island as a holy mountain.
Ralf: So it was part of the Byzantine Empire then, at that time.
Lina: Exactly.
Ralf: I think — it's located — so, do you know where it is located in Greece, just out of curiosity? So it's not directly on the southern part, then, I assume, when you say it's the peninsula, because, for some reason, I thought it was more to the southern part of Greece, but it's not.
Lina: So, no, in Greece there are, like, three really marked peninsulas, and it's the upper peninsula of these three.
Ralf: So, northeastern part of Greece, then, okay.
Lina: Exactly.
Lina: By the 10th century — I mean, the monastic structure actually was officially born as we see it today. So, it started first with Athanasius the Athonite — he was a saint, or he's a saint now — asking the Emperor Nikephoros II to actually organize the region as a monastery.
Ralf: And you said before, like, he was the person that it's named after the mount, right? Or did I misunderstand or something, the mountain?
Lina: No, the mount Athos is named because the giant Athos threw a rock to Poseidon.
Ralf: Okay, so it's a coincidence that the saint and the titan — or the giant — were similarly named.
Lina: I'm pretty sure there is certain connections, because, I mean, famous people tend to change their name, but I'm not really sure.
Ralf: Got it. Okay, yeah.
Lina: That's probably not the case, it's just a coincidence, but in this case, yeah, it's really close to the name. Um, in 1972 CE, actually, is when the Mount Athos started to be recognized as a place of prayer and monks.
Ralf: In 1972, so, quite late.
Lina: Yeah, 972 — not 1972
Ralf: Ah, not 1972 — okay
Lina: Nine, seven, two — not 1972. I was like, wait, but that's — like, that's one thousand years after Jesus Christ. I was like, is it still a lot of time? But anyway, let's just — the first charter of Mount Athos actually was officially put in a statement called Tragos.
Lina: Why Tragos? Because it was made in goat skin, and Tragos, it translates to goat in Greek. This document, basically, is still in the capital of Karyes, in the region of Mount Athos today.
Ralf: Ah, that's the regional capital, then?
Lina: Exactly. Because it's a region, it's not just, like, a little place.
Ralf: Ah, okay, the whole region is called Athos, and it's not just this particular place.
Lina: Exactly, no, it is the whole peninsula.
Ralf: Got it.
Lina: So, what is this Tragos thing? So, basically, it's a document who was drafted by Saint Athanasius the Athonite — yeah? We come back to the topic of naming, it's really similar.
Ralf: I'm not gonna ask a stupid question again, don't worry. I got it the first time you explained it to me.
Lina: And, basically, he wrote it with the monk of Euthymios, and it's the same guy that asked the Emperor Nikephoros II to actually create what is called the Great Lavra, which is, okay, the recognition that they are a holy mountain or a holy region.
Ralf: And all of this goes back to the story about the Virgin Mary, supposedly, which they used before to justify like it's becoming a holy place.
Lina: So, yeah, so just not to confuse our audience. Basically, there was a lot of communities centuries before Jesus Christ, then they basically left. Then by the 4th century, this story started to become popular, and a lot of monks and people that wanted to consecrate their souls to pray started to move to this region. That was between the 4th and the 9th century, but Athanasius the Athonite requested to actually become a holy place, and he requested it to the Byzantine Emperor.
Ralf: And with the justification of all the centuries that had already had its importance, like in the pilgrimage and for the people that traveled around there, and rooted in this story about the Virgin having arrived there.
Lina: Exactly, and honestly, it was, I think, a little bit inevitable.
Ralf: Inevetable?
Lina: Inevitable. Inevetable.
Ralf: Not to be avoided — like, okay? Like our mistakes in English?
Lina: Exactly, exactly. I'm sorry, I just remind you that if it's not obvious, I cannot speak English perfectly.
Ralf: We're both not native speakers, but anyway, yeah.
Lina: Continuing. So basically, it was really hard to say no, because by this time there was a lot of monasteries. There is not only one, there are several. I will mention how many a little bit after here. And basically, this Tragos — well, I will explain a little bit in detail — but it was signed by the next Byzantine Emperor, John I Tzimiskes. Sorry if I mispronounced the name. Um, well, basically the Tragos established the administrative structure of what is in the island until today, and the main points included it. The first one, it formalized the role of the Protos, which is actually the leader of the community, or the most important person, basically the mayor of the community. And the Assembly at Karyes as capital of the whole region.
Ralf: So, if I understand it correctly, like, basically the whole, let's say, hierarchical structure of this peninsula is based on a document that was created like more than 1000 years ago and has survived until today, this kind of structure?
Lina: Exactly. Now you are starting to get the point of Mount Athos. So, yeah, basically yes. And the law of these Tragos is still functioning today, as it was 1000 years ago.
Ralf: Makes me wonder — I mean, like, I'm quite sure there are a lot of other places in the world where older laws are in place, but I mean, if you would ask me right now what kind of law that is still in place comes into your mind, I think I would spontaneously not know any law that is older than this right now. For sure there are laws that are older and that are still in place, but wow, that's super impressive.
Lina: Yeah, and it gets more interesting, believe me. It also — these Tragos also set rules to allow hermits and communal monasteries to live side by side without conflict, just to make sure that there is not going to be any infighting. It also regulated how monasteries could trade goods — so, for instance, wine and wood — to prevent any commercial interests to actually overshadow spiritual life, so in terms they really cannot have markets, in comillas. And they stipulate the Abaton.
Lina: What is the Abaton? It's a prohibition of women, female animals, and beardless youths on the peninsula to preserve the monks' focus. Until today they are not allowed to have any women in the peninsula, any female animals, and any beardless youth people.
Ralf: So basically no female beings are supposed to be allowed on this peninsula?
Lina: Yes.
Ralf: Oh wow.
Lina: So the Abaton — the official ban of women — was actually formalized afterwards by Emperor Constantine Monomachos in the year 1045 CE. And pretty much all of this continued for a long time. Nevertheless, during the Middle Ages — I mean, I'm talking between the 11th and the 15th century — they had a lot of issues. One of them were, of course, the Crusades. In 1204, after the Fourth Crusade — you know, the Fourth Crusade actually sacked Constantinople — the monks had to seek, actually, protection from the Pope. Then later, the Catalans came — that was the Catalan Grand Company raid, between 1307 and 1309, so around two years of them sacking Mount Athos and taking everything that they could. Unfortunately, this was really devastating for the peninsula, because all around, before that, there were around 300 monasteries standing, and by the time they left, there were only 35.
Ralf: And the rest was,so?
Lina: Destroyed.
Lina: So, basically, they pretty much, even with all of these issues, never really changed. And then there was a period called the Rise of Hesychasm — I hope I pronounced it correctly. And basically, this is at the time after the 15th century, when they really focused on perpetual prayer, and things got even more enclosed in this community. This was championed by Gregory Palamas, which was one of the most influential monks by the time. Then Ottoman rule came, and there was a little bit of a shift. When the Ottomans captured Thessaloniki in 1430, the monks basically submitted to Turkish rule to preserve their autonomy, and they actually won this kind of conflict. Nevertheless, of course, it was not for free — so the Turkish asked for really heavy taxes, which led the community, or the monks, to live in extreme poverty. And basically, to survive, many monasteries had to switch from this communal system — when they couldn't trade, but actually just exchange goods when they needed it — to actually being allowed to own private property and eat alone, because by this time, they had to eat all together. Despite all of this hardship, the Athonite Academy — which is, you know, of the Athonite guy before — was founded in 1748 near Vatopedi, and it became basically a place of Greek enlightenment and study for the monks. So, they kind of survived by switching a little bit these Tragos rules, but in the end of the day, they, I mean, they had to. And when the Turkish left, they could actually stay with their ways of living.
Ralf: And at that time, it was still, um — do you know if they had then rebuilt some of the monasteries that were destroyed, or was it still that there was a reduced number of monasteries? I think the question that I have here is, did you find out in any of your research if it ever came back to the amount of monasteries it had at its peak, or is it, until today, more of a reduced amount of monasteries that are found in this region?
Lina: Actually, no, unfortunately, it never recovered, so today, there are 20 monasteries in place. By the time it was devastated by the Catalans, they went from around 300 down to 35, but by today, they are around 20 standing.
Ralf: So, it never came back to the amount of monasteries it had at its peak?
Lina: No, never, unfortunately. And it's also important to mention — even though I will mention it a little bit later — no, not all of them can be visited. Some of them are completely closed, for outsiders, I mean.
Lina: So, now talking a little bit of what happened after the Ottoman rules, we're talking a little bit more in the modern era. In the 19th century, there was the Greek War of Independence from Turkish repression, and Greeks were able to gain independence from Turkish rule. And by the 19th century, actually, the tsars of Russia actually provided a lot of patronage to the community in Mount Athos, and they gave a lot of money to St. Panteleimon Monastery — hope I'm not mispronouncing it again — and today it's one of the biggest monasteries in the area. Finally, around 1926, Mount Athos was officially recognized as a self-governing part of Greece, and its special status is warranted by the constitution. There was a low population until 1971, when there was a massive spiritual renewal. And all of these 20 monasteries started to become full of life, and a lot of people came to actually live there afterwards. You already know it, but Mount Athos was inscribed as a UNESCO World Heritage Site, of course. This happened, yes, that's why we're talking about it.
Ralf: Really? So — surprising — we're talking about World Heritage, right?
Lina: This was inscribed in 1988, because, I mean, it has a really special meeting point between spiritual history, artistic, natural history, and of course — it's amazing landscape, because it's also really pretty there. Today, it includes more than 15 open monasteries around the whole island, and around five that are completely enclosed.
Ralf: And they are still actively used — so, let me rephrase: the ones that are closed, are they closed because they are still used for monastic purposes, and, like, just to not disturb them, or are there other reasons why they are closed?
Lina: No, no, no. It's just that they are really enclosed communities. Many of them are Orthodox Christians, and they are really enclosed in their heritage and customs.
Ralf: So, like, really just to preserve their way of living. I got it.
Lina: And I will explain a little more on that. So, now we are going to talk about some facts. I don't think they are fun facts this time, but they are definitely facts.
Ralf: Just facts. We're switching this section — not fun facts anymore, just facts.
Lina: The no-woman rule stands, and for more than a thousand years, no woman has actually stood on the peninsula. Regarding the animal exceptions — the ban, as I mentioned before, well, it also includes female animals. The only exception for this is actually cats, because they help to hunt mice. And, basically, they were like, okay, do we have mouses, or do we have cats, females, that can reproduce, and can have more cats to avoid more mouses?
Lina: And they preferred this — the cats.
Ralf: Again, another example of how cats defy any kind of rules in history, right? I mean, the rebel animal, par excellence.
Lina: Exactly. There is only one other exception that happened a little bit afterwards, which is the hens, because the monks needed eggs.
Ralf: Yeah, it's difficult to get eggs from male chickens, yeah.
Lina: Funny thing, they not only use the eggs for eating, they also use the shells for painting.
Ralf: Oh.
Lina: Yeah, they did like the white part.
Ralf: Okay, I mean — anyway, I can imagine that it's really difficult to enforce this rule. I guess the rule is not against all animals, but more like, well, domesticated animals, right? Because, I mean, how would you ensure that, for the wildlife on this island, there are no female animals? Because, well, you cannot really control that. So, I guess the rule is more like: you cannot have female animals that are domesticated.
Lina: Yeah, no, for sure — I mean, you cannot prevent female birds from coming onto the island, huh?
Ralf: So, they would not actively hunt and kill female wild animals?
Lina: No, no, — I think that it's not that.
Ralf: So no females domesticated.
Lina: Exactly, and I think that it comes to the fact that, you know, these are guys that have, in many cases, not seen many women in their lives, you know what I mean? So, it's just to prevent that kind of thing. I mean, I think you know what I mean. The interesting part — I mean, there are a lot of interesting parts about this peninsula — but one of them is actually going so far as, hey, we need to not have female... cat, cat, — what is the name of that?
Ralf: What do you mean with cat?
Lina: Catter. Cata, cat — when they have animals in their... uh.
Ralf: A cattle? Cattle —
Lina: Cattle —
Lina: Exactly. So, I mean, this is really an enclosed community. That's what I want to make clear to everybody. There is also something really interesting — basically, they live in the past. The peninsula still uses the Julian calendar, meaning they are 13 days behind the rest of the world.
Ralf: Oh, okay.
Lina: And there is an even weirder fact. They use Byzantine time, where the new day begins at sunset rather than at midnight. So, they do not have the same time as the rest of the world. They count one o'clock — sorry — they count twelve o'clock when the sunset falls.
Ralf: But that means, then, that they have a really moving time period, because the time changes when the sun rises and sets. So they do not have the same as we do — a really stable day, or a stable hour rhythm. It's moving, depending on when the sun rises and the sun sets.
Lina: Exactly. And that was how it was made in Byzantine times.
Lina: Yep, interesting fact. They also are a meat-free zone, which means the monks follow a really strict diet consisting mostly of vegetables, seafood, and legumes, fruits, eggs, but meat is entirely excluded all year round. I mean, I'm talking about red meat, chicken, pork, cow.
Ralf: Yeah, because it's not a strictly vegetarian diet — because then there would also not be seafood.
Lina: No — it's red meat.
Ralf: But it's, then, meat from land animals, okay.
Lina: The Tragos, as I mentioned before, which is the ruling aspect of all the island, is still today in the central administration building of Karyes, which is the capital of Mount Athos. And it's treated like it's a holy paper — not just a piece of ink and skin. It's also, like, the birth certificate of the Athonite monastic state, which is how they call themselves — Athonite, remember, the guy. The document is actually physically quite large. It's a long scroll that bears the signature of the Emperor Tzimiskes — I mentioned the one before. Funny thing — he signed in red ink, which was a privilege reserved strictly for imperial use for really, really important documents. And that just gives a little bit more importance to this Tragos. There is two points of controversy, and here I will just mention it really quick. The first one is, during World War II, the monks reportedly asked Adolf Hitler to be the High Protector, to avoid the destruction of the monastery — a request that, supposedly, because there is no real proof, he actually accepted. This is controversy number one.
Ralf: Not controversial at all. I can imagine asking Hitler to be your protector.
Lina: They — I guess they just assumed he was gonna win. The second one, and it's a little bit more recent — even though they are so enclosed and out of any modern technology or anything, they have actually been in scandalous geopolitical storms, because there are allegations that the Russian government has used certain monasteries out of these 20 as a base for intelligence operations, to report on Greek activities and Greek political activities.
Ralf: There has been a surprising amount of, let's say, connection with Russia then — like the way you were talking about the patronage by the Russian Tsar, and now that you mentioned there were theories about it being used for Russian intelligence activities. I have to admit that's surprising to me — I would not have immediately thought that a peninsula in Greece has, in more recent history, that connection with Russia.
Lina: Exactly. I mean, they are really highly Orthodox communities, with a lot of connections to the Russian church.
Ralf: Yeah, which are also Orthodox Christians, yeah.
Lina: Exactly. And basically, well, this is just how — as I mentioned, these are controversies, nothing has been proved so far. Again, they are closed communities, so even proving it could be really risky and difficult.
Lina: Now, stories. So I want to give a little bit more information about the Abaton, which is the ban of women. This is a special rule in the Tragos. Well, basically the reason why it's more like a cultural aspect is to avoid that monks are actually falling in sin, but there are also some historical aspects that, like, incentivized this Abaton to be created. The first one is that, by the 5th century, Empress Placidia — actually there is a story, no? This is not real, but I mean, not real in the sense that it's probably not true.
Ralf: Yes, it's like — it's not proven it happened. It could be, it's like a myth.
Lina: That is — it's a myth. Exactly. Sorry, I was like, blub, blub, blub. In the 5th century, Empress Placidia attempted to enter one of the monasteries, only to be stopped by a miraculous voice from an icon of the Virgin Mary, telling her to stand still and not proceed, because this is prohibited for her. So this is one of the stories that say, yeah, we need to create the Abaton because the Virgin Mary doesn't let women in. There was another story — that's from the clever Empress Helena of the Serbian Emperor Stefan Dušan. She was really a religious person, and to avoid breaking the law during the 14th-century plague, she visited the mountain but never actually put a foot on the ground. So, but she actually visited — so how they did it was that she was carried everywhere in a litter. Of course, by this time she had to visit it because — she wanted to protect herself from the plague, and this was an enclosed community. And one of the most incredible stories is actually of — he's called Mihailo Tolotos. He was a monk, and I think, I mean, this is actually proof, this is real. He died in 1938 at the age of 82, and is the only man in history to claim to have never seen a woman. He was raised in one of the monasteries from infancy. He was left as a baby in the monastery. His mother died in childbirth, and he never saw any woman, because he never left the peninsula. And this — there is actually a photo of him. So, I will try to see if we can put it in our Instagram post, at @worldheritagerookies — marketing time. But you can also Google it. He's real. Actually, he's the only kind of proven person to have never met a female in his life.
Ralf: That is — yeah, I mean, as I mentioned, it can happen when you unfortunately do not meet your mother. But like you said, it's really — I would not call it an achievement, because, well, it is something that is really controversial, as you said. But, yeah, it never occurred to me that it could be that a person there will have never seen a woman in their life, because most people will, of course, at least meet their mother. But, yeah, when his mom died during childbirth and he was raised the whole time — oh, wow, okay, that's really hard to wrap your head around, yeah.
Lina: Yeah, I mean, it is not a common occurrence, that's why he's the only one — because they do not raise children, of course. Normally monks came when they are a little bit older, especially when they have beards — remember, they have a ban on young people who do not have beards, so they have at least to wait that the beards are start to happen. And also, normally they are growing up with women — like, there has not been, before they come onto the island, to not have seen women in any way. So, of course, this is the only person that actually can be proved to have never seen a woman, which for me is actually really interesting, because imagine yourself in a scenario where you only met half of the population — you'd think, I think, that he probably knew females existed, but it's like a — it's like a dragon, it's like a special creature.
Ralf: Out of mythology.
Lina: Exactly, how interesting.
Lina: Right, so, well, now it comes my debate — it's regarding this Abaton. In modern times, the European Union has repeatedly pressured Greece to lift the ban on women, citing, of course, gender equality laws that are primary in Europe. But, of course, the monastic community has completely resisted, fearing that this entering of women would destroy their spiritual isolation — the isolation that they kind of guarded for the 1,000 years. And this is basically, pretty much, the question: what do you think about the ban on women — what do you think, should it be maintained or not?
Ralf: I think this... first really excellent question — as you mentioned, it is just leaning itself from this place. For me, the challenge here is, we have two values here that are important to me, that are clashing. The first is, obviously, the fact about equality between genders — I do not believe in any way that this is still modern, in a way. And, as I have mentioned also in previous episodes — for example, when it comes to visiting, I think we were talking about Mesa Verde, and the question of whether people should have access to it — I do not think anything that relates to culture should be excluded for people. So, I think also the point of World Heritage is that, unless there's really, really dangerous circumstances associated with it, you should be able to experience it, and to see what our world has to offer. So, obviously, from an inclusion perspective, I do not think it should be maintained. But that has been clashing with me, with another value that is important to me, which is respect, obviously, towards the history of a place — and this has clearly been one of the core identities of this community, to have this in place. And, basically, you are asking here: should one value supersede the other? If I had to make the choice, I would say I would like to see the ban lifted, because, in my opinion, it is actually sometimes more important to be accessible, and to allow people to experience it, instead of keeping it. But it's a really hard question, because you're basically asking: can we just disregard their way of living for 1,000 years, which, on the other hand, is also supposed to be protected by World Heritage, and it's part of this. So, there is, in my opinion, no easy answer.
Lina: I think that — I mean, that's exactly why, what I was working on when I was doing this episode. I am a female, and the fact that I will never be able — this is one of the little World Heritage Sites that I will not be able to visit — is kind of sad, because it is actually really interesting monasteries. But at the same time, living tradition — I'll spoil it, I'm going to spoil it right away — it's one of the criteria of why it's a World Heritage Site: it's maintained its tradition for more than 1,000 years.
Ralf: Exactly.
Lina: One of the little — only places in the world that has maintained this status. Honestly, I do not think that it should be banned — sorry, it should be lifted completely. We should maybe look for ways of working around it. One of the things that I was discussing in one of the blogs — because you can, we can visit, females can visit, I will explain a little bit how, but we cannot actually put our foot on the peninsula. So, something I was thinking — it was like, yeah, the intention is for monks to not see females, because, of course, maintaining their purity. Well, there are 20 places — what if you just... go to one of them, you know what I mean? Like, moving all the monks to one place for a good afternoon? And allow women — that could be one solution, but I was just putting ideas out. But, yeah, at the end of the day, I don't think that it should be lifted. It is tradition, and this is exactly why it's a World Heritage Site — because it's one of the places in the world that pretty much lived the same since 1,000 years ago. I mean, this is one of the untouched, virgin places that we see really rarely right now in our communities.
Ralf: But then, for example, my question is — and I do not know if you found this in your research — are they allowed to have any kind of media around? Because my other question would then be: well, if the intention was to have no female visitors, or even female animals, there, to avoid temptation for the monks — you have temptation everywhere today. And, I mean, when you just look at what is shown in the media, this is then also something. So, does that follow through as well? I could imagine that it's like this, because I know in many monasteries you're not allowed to have any kind of private property, and... topics. So, here's a question: well, by today, there are other ways how you can lose your focus, instead of just having female visitors. And I fully get your point — try to find a solution that works on both sides. But, like you mentioned before, it's really a clash of two different topics. In a way, you're discriminating against a whole gender. And at the same time, if you would not do this, you're disrespecting the tradition of a whole community. So, I think there is no easy answer to this question. It depends on what you think is more important: is it more important that you respect their way of living for over a millennium, or is it more important that you say it should be accessible for men and women?
Lina: Yeah, that's exactly why it has been so difficult for even governments to find an agreement. And, in the end of the day — well, first, to answer your first question — well, there are tourists. So, of course, they have seen cell phones, and they know they exist. But they themselves cannot have them as their property. So, yeah, they know modernity exists. Probably they know the internet exists. But, of course, also, the people that reign over the island — the big monks, let's say, the most prosperous monks — of course, they probably have to also get into agreement with political statements, because, once again, they are their own state, but they are inside the state of Greece. And they only maintain this special governability because of, like, a constant communication with the Greek politics. So, of course, they have to travel, for instance, and this is something — it's not that they are completely closed. That's impossible in today's modernity. But it is true that there are certain regulations to avoid them getting into contact. So, for instance — I was going to mention it later — but one of the things is that you cannot actually make photos of the monks when, for instance, somebody's visiting, unless you have special permission, and it's under really special circumstances. That's one of the things. So, people don't even know how they look, and so on, unless you actually visit as a pilgrim. Let's say, once again, remember, it's not that you go and do a tour — you actually go on a pilgrimage there. You go to pray.
Ralf: Yeah, get it.
Lina: So, well, this is an open debate. It will be kept as an open debate for many years to come. And yes, unfortunately, today, women cannot visit. That's how it is. And whatever it is, good or bad, it's what it is.
Lina: Now, this is maybe a good part to jump to the next section, which is why it's a UNESCO World Heritage Site. I'm not asking you how many criteria it has, because, well, it's a hint, but we kind of know it has six. So, it's criteria one, two, four, five, six, and seven, and I will explain why for each of them. So, first of all, the site is recognized for its historical value. Mount Athos has been the spiritual center of the Orthodox community since 1054, and has maintained its autonomous state since the Byzantine era. So, its historical value is completely understandable. Then, its cultural value, in connection to the historical value — that's criteria number two, and number four and five. First, it has an artistic influence. The peninsula includes the Athonite School of Painting, which has profoundly influenced the history of Orthodox art. That's one of the reasons why this criterion applies. The architectural layout of the monasteries is modeled by religious buildings as far as Russia — so, many of the buildings of the monasteries that were created 1,000 years ago actually have replicas in Orthodox communities today in Russia. There is also a lot of architectural marvels. The 20 monasteries have different, complex, spiritual fortresses. So, when you look up Mount Athos — and I will also post it on our site — one of the most majestic ones is actually the biggest one, which looks like a castle. Of course, this housing has unique treasures. They have really intricate frescoes, because they are painted by hand. And they are all made in mosaics, because, of course, they were influenced by Orthodox communities 1,000 years ago. And the third reason is because, as I mentioned before, it's living tradition. I mean, the fact that the monasteries are pretty much living museums, and completely preserve their initial rituals since Byzantine times. For instance, they still chant — they sing in Byzantine chants.
Ralf: Oh wow.
Lina: And they do timeless liturgies that have remained pretty much unchanged over 1,000 years. So, they are still praying as they prayed 1,000 years ago — made it completely majestic. The last part of the cultural value is actually, they have a lot of treasures. So, because they were pretty much enclosed in time, they have a lot of wealth from the Byzantine heritage times. So they have a lot of things that are preserved since the Byzantine times, including really rare manuscripts, holy relics from the crusades during the Byzantine times — sorry. And they have a lot of icons and miraculous objects that are still inside the monasteries. So, some of them are visible to pilgrims, some of them are not. So, the peninsula has maintained a pristine ecosystem. Thanks to the isolation, and also to the Abaton rule, today there are more than 33,000 hectares of property completely protected from anthropogenic threats. What are these threats? These threats are basically environmental dangers, imbalances, damages caused by human activity, by construction. They have absolutely natural processes, and actually the term comes from the Greek anthropos, human, and genesis, origin — that's what gives us the word anthropogenic. It comes from Greek. So, it's quite interesting — that's the reason why. I don't know why I got this fact, but yeah, anyway.
Ralf: It's sometimes very adorable what facts come out to you.
Lina: And they also have a really harmonious landscape. So, Mount Athos is considered a really unique cultural landscape, because while it is a traditional place, its architecture and ways of farming and handcrafting things have pretty much stayed natural — which means they do not use any type of metallurgic processes or chemical processes to produce any of the goods that they use on a daily basis. Everything is natural — like, from how to make a table to how to call somebody, they probably still send messages. I'm not really sure about that.
Ralf: It feels like — it's like a bubble stuck in time a bit, right?
Lina: Exactly.
Lina: That's exactly what makes Mount Athos so special, because it's pretty much a place that was stuck in the Middle Ages. So the peninsula functions as a closed ecosystem for a lot of species. So, for flora, the peninsula contains more than 1,400 species and subspecies, and 14 of them are completely endemic to the place. There are also 350 special species of mushrooms here. Interesting fact. Now for fauna — of course, they have a really well-preserved natural environment. They have around 41 species of mammals, 173 species of birds, and many of these — many of the bird ones especially — are completely endemic to the peninsula of Athos. They also have a really special agroforestry tradition, which means their soil is one of the most preserved soils in the world, because they don't use any chemicals to produce any kind of vegetables and fruits — which means they do completely organic farming. And, actually, they have been researching the soil, because it's one of the most preserved farming soils in the world. And yeah, this is pretty much a little summary of why Mount Athos is a Weltkultur.....
Ralf: You wanted to take the German, right? Weltkulturerbe.
Lina: Weltkulturerbe — oh my God, yes.
Ralf: I'm sorry for you having to mix all those languages, but I think that takes now the top of our list so far when it comes to criteria. I don't think we have any World Heritage Sites so far in this podcast that met six criteria, if I remember correctly.
Lina: Well, you are probably more aware of that, but maybe this is the one that has the most criteria so far, yes.
Ralf: Yeah, I think also the ones in the past, mostly of them had five — so, I would have to check again, but yeah, interesting. I mean, like you said, it's a really difficult topic, because what keeps it from being accessible is part of what makes it so special.
Lina: And makes it unique, and a place that can really be studied, because it conserves how people lived 1,000 years ago. There's not any other place in the world that is similar to that. So, yeah, quite interesting.
Lina: Now, how to visit — of course, this is the last part of our podcast, always.
Ralf: Criteria 1: be a man.
Lina: Be a man, actually, yes. Today I will present two different sections — how to visit if you are a man, and how to visit if you are a woman. So, if you are a man, you can enter the peninsula. Every visitor must obtain a special residence permit called a diamonitirion. Daily visitor numbers are restricted to a maximum of 100 Orthodox Christians and 10 non-Orthodox pilgrims. They are also open to other types of Christians and Catholics as well. Daily visitors are restricted like that just to prevent the excessive amount of tourism. In order to come, you must contact the Pilgrims' Bureau well in advance to receive your permit, the diamonitirion that I mentioned before. There are offices in Thessaloniki and Ouranoupoli, in Greece. So, yes, just to understand it, you need to go there and ask for permission — it cannot be anywhere else in the world. There are different types of permits. So, there is this general permit, which is valid for three nights and four days across different monasteries — so, you are going to be doing a hop-on, hop-off monastery. Yes, I know, I have to mention it, I've had this joke since I was studying it. And an individual permit, issued by a specific monastery, when, basically, you stay in that monastery the whole stay. So, you have to pay — the typical fee for Orthodox Christians is 25 euros for this diamonitirion permit, and 30 euros for non-Orthodox visitors. And there is a special fee of 10 euros for students, soldiers, or people with disabilities. You must pick up the physical permit on the day of departure at the Pilgrims' Bureau office in Ouranoupoli, or in Thessaloniki, as I mentioned before, and you need to present your ID and passport to be able to get the transportation to the island.
Lina: So, how to access the island — let's put an example. You Ralf go and request your permission. Actually, I made a mistake before — yeah, no, you can request your permission by phone or by the website — well, it's not a park, it's actually a community — but you can request it that way. But you need to go physically to pick it up. Exactly — not to request it, to pick it up. So, of course, it's an isolated place, so the only way you can actually reach the peninsula is by sea. That's why normally it's from Ouranoupoli — there are boats going to Mount Athos.
Ralf: So, even though it's a peninsula, and therefore partially connected to the land, you have to arrive mostly by sea.
Lina: Not — not mostly. Only.
Ralf: Only, okay.
Lina: So, one of the Byzantine kings actually did build a connection to the peninsula — a little bit accessible, but it was closed off afterward. Most pilgrims arrive, as I mentioned, via Ouranoupoli, which gives regular ferries — it's not a boat, it's actually a ferry.
Lina: Now, how to travel internally in the peninsula. So, once you are in there, you can travel between monasteries by normal, traditional walking. These traditional walks are actually from Byzantine times, so you will be using the roads that were created 1,000 years ago. Or, there is another option, which is an off-road vehicle and taxi that is also being run by the monks. So, it's like a kind of tiny market of transportation they have. But most of the people walk.
Ralf: But — how are they transporting you? Like, via a wagon, or how is it that they are?
Lina: No, they have cars.
Ralf: Ah, okay.
Lina: I mean, they have ferries, so they can have cars — but these cars, you have to book in advance.
Ralf: I see, okay, because they are probably pretty rare on the island.
Lina: Exactly. And most of the people actually walk there, and it's really one of the attractions — I'll mention it a little bit later.
Ralf: But you have to stay in one dedicated monastery, you mentioned, right? So, you will not be able to walk from one monastery to the next and sleep there. So, while you are on the island, you have to sleep and stay in one of the monasteries?
Lina: No, no, no. What I mentioned before — there are two types of permits. So, the first one is actually the hop-on, hop-off monastery permit. So, you are three nights on the island, and you can be in three different monasteries.
Ralf: Ah, okay. So, you are only allowed to do this, then, when you have the specific—
Lina: —type one, or the one that just allows you to go to the one that you requested.
Ralf: Okay, okay. Got it, got it.
Lina: Exactly.
Lina: Of course, it's critical to know that the monastery gates close at sunset and do not open until sunrise. So, for pilgrims — it's not common that you go completely by yourself; normally you have an Orthodox community that goes with you — but if you're a man, once again, and if you want to go to the next monastery, you have to remember that you have to arrive at the next monastery before sunset. Otherwise, you will have to sleep in the wild. They do not open under any circumstances — I think that was really clear in one of the pilgrims' websites that I found. So, how does the accommodation work? Well, this is a stay on a holy mountain, so, of course, it's all focused on a spiritual experience. It's not a hotel stay — so, just to be clear, you shouldn't go expecting a luxury experience. The guests stay in the monastery guesthouse, which is called the archontariki. The accommodations are typically really basic. They are clean, of course, but they pretty much reflect the monks' ascetic lifestyle, so you will probably see a little table and your bed — that's pretty much it. It is essential to arrange the stay with the specific monasteries in advance. So, you can be in three, for instance, with this first type of permit — you can be in any monasteries that you choose, but you need to discuss it with them, you need to book it with them in advance. They are also on a daily schedule, so visitors are expected to follow the monastic rhythm, which means, if you go there, you have to do what the monks do. So, they need to attend liturgical services, often before dawn — which means that you will normally be praying really early in the morning. Then, you have to share communal meals — they have a specific name for it, called trapeza — like any other monk. And there is a period of complete silence on the island, so you also have to respect that — you cannot say anything during certain specific hours. Of course, even if you are a man, you have to commit to certain rules — one of them is that you need to dress modestly, which means you cannot wear shorts, or sleeveless shirts, even if it's summer and it's over 40 degrees. And, what I mentioned before, photography is completely prohibited — if you want to photograph the island, that's okay, but you cannot photograph the monks, unless you have special permission.
Lina: Now, one of the things that pilgrims do most, apart from praying, and this spiritual side, is actually hiking — what I mentioned before. There is a lot of beauty in the natural landscape, so the peninsula offers extensive trekking opportunities. The first one is actually reaching the peak of Mount Athos, which is 2,033 meters above sea level. It's a demanding route, so it's just expected for professional hikers. Of course, climbers need to have appropriate equipment, need to be really conscious of the weather forecast, and it's necessary for climbers to have a printed navigation map, because, of course, there is no mobile signal, there is nothing light-driven or electricity-driven in the wilderness. There is also, when you want to climb, a shelter in the middle of the way, at a higher altitude, in case you want to stay there. But this has to be extremely planned, because — this is called the Panagia Refuge. It's not maintained by any monk, it's just a place for climbers to stay when they are going up the mountain.
Ralf: So, you basically really have to plan your visit there, and also then your stay on the peninsula. It needs a lot of planning in advance.
Lina: Exactly. So, first, you need to make sure that you arrange your permission, then you need to make sure you arrange your stay, then you need to make sure what activities you are going to do, in advance, in order to plan appropriately.
Ralf: If you're a man.
Lina: If you are a man, of course. There is another topic that even has to be mentioned when you're a man.
Lina: The Athonite diet is healthy and simple, so you will eat the same as the monks — you will not eat any red meat, because it's just not cooked there, so you will be eating vegetables, legumes, and seafood mostly. Once again, you cannot even bring meat — it's completely prohibited. And, during communal meals, monks often eat in silence while, of course, listening to sacred readings. So, you are expected to do the same.
Lina: Now, this was for men — if you're a man, if you plan, you can go there. Now, if you were a woman—
Ralf: Oh — may I guess? Let me guess: there are specific tours, or so, where you are allowed to go by boat around the island, the peninsula, to see it.
Lina: Yes, exactly. Ding ding ding.
Ralf: Ha!
Lina: Exactly. So, when you're a woman, you can still see the island from far away. There are certain cruise lines — most of them departing also from Ouranoupoli — or there are also some boats from Ormos and Ormos Panagias. But they are sailing along the coast — sailing the whole peninsula coast at a distance of 500 meters. They cannot go closer than that.
Ralf: Ah, so — because they mentioned you're not allowed to set foot on the island, but do you know — is that because there's a rule that they are not allowed to go closer, or is it just as a way of respect? Do you know that, by chance?
Lina: I think that it's more for the.... Well, first of all, they are cruise ships, so most of them are probably quite big boats.
Ralf: True. Yeah.
Lina: So even reaching the island could be difficult. But also, this peninsula is really rocky — I mean, you have to see it in photos, but there are really high cliffs.
Ralf: Ah, okay.
Lina: So even reaching it, exactly. So you have to really go to the specific port, and you'll have to be really close in order to be able to see it. So it really makes no sense — probably better to see it in photos.
Ralf: My thought was also — if you are coming closer, there's also a higher risk, in quotation marks, that monks might see female tourists.
Lina: They can see female tourists, because that's another part — actually, on certain specific boats, the monks bring relics to the people, to the women, so they can see miraculous icons, holy relics. And they also can talk to the women and discuss — there are special monks, so not all of them are allowed to do this. Most likely, high-rank monks are allowed, but they can actually bring relics to the cruises.
Ralf: Ah, okay, so it is not that — so it is really then about entering the peninsula of Athos, and not that, specifically, that there is no contact allowed between—
Lina: I mean, it is not contact allowed for most of the monks — there is no contact allowed — but that doesn't mean some of the monks cannot, really. I mean, that's what I mentioned — most likely, I didn't research that specifically, I have to admit, but most likely it is just allowed for high-rank monks, also because they are gonna be in contact with holy relics, and they are quite precious. I'm not — something I do not remember if I read is whether they can talk to them, but I think they can ask some questions. Maybe it is not necessarily about how the monks live, or about the relics, but, in one of the pilgrim sites, I think I read that they can actually ask questions about the holy relics, most likely. So, yeah, I mean, this is how you can visit — you can visit by boat, just by seeing it. Most of the boats also give historical details about the island, each of the monasteries. Because — there's 20 — not all of them are visible from the boats, just to be clear. Some of them are inland, but some of them — the most majestic one, the one that you will see when you Google it — is the one that looks like a castle, and it's the biggest one. So, it's the one that is also the southernmost.
Ralf: Got it, okay.
Lina: So, yeah, that's Mount Athos for you. I hope you like it — this is a really timeless place, really interesting, but for half the population in the world, not able to visit, at least not inland.
Ralf: Yeah, that's — thanks again, as usual, for all the information. Super interesting, super unique places, also.
Ralf: I think it's now time for the verdict, right? Would we go, or would we not go?
Lina: I know my verdict — I would not, actually. I would be interested to be in the boat, especially one of these boats when the monks bring the relics, because they are apparently amazing.
Ralf: And, I mean, if you had to ask me, I would probably say I would not put it on our to-go list, because—
Lina: You will have to go alone?
Ralf: That is actually the main reason, because one thing why we started this podcast is because we have this hobby together. So, I feel for myself, obviously — yeah, if I could go, yeah, I could go, but—
Lina: We could go by boat, both of us.
Ralf: Yeah, but — but that doesn't feel for me like it's the full experience. I mean, this is, then, for me — we would have this as a solution that we have to take in order to experience it in the first place. And then, well, that's, then, for me, not the full experience. Because the way you describe it to me, what makes this place unique is its way of living, and it has preserved for more than a millennium — to see how the monastic life goes there, how they experience it, to see how the routines are, that you eat with the monks and everything. So, this is, for me, what makes this World Heritage Site so unique as an experience. And then, honestly, I personally prefer to not go at all, because going without you is, without any question, obviously, for me — no, no, no, that's a no-go.
Lina: Yeah, but — you have been to many World Heritage Sites alone since you met me.
Ralf: Yes, I have been, but this is, like, where I say: well, I'm gonna go with you either again, or you might also go there by yourself, so... We're gonna keep fighting about it the whole day. Ah, no, but, all jokes aside, yeah, that's, I think, for me, the reason — when we're not able to experience it together, I don't think it's that nice. And, yeah, the solution via the boat, I think it's a good approach to make sure that at least female visitors can get some impression of it, but it's not the full experience, yeah.
Lina: I mean, I think that it — I don't think it's gonna be on our priority list, for sure, but if we ever had the opportunity, I would not miss it, because I have seen the photos, and I have seen how majestic it is, how beautiful it is, even from far away. So, I would say, maybe it's not in our top ten, but wherever we can go, I will be happily taking the cruise.
Ralf: Then let's see what pops up.
Lina: So, that was our 16th episode of World Heritage Rookies. I hope you liked it. I'm sorry, once again, if I mispronounced anything — most likely everything — but thank you for your patience.
Ralf: And thank you very much for listening. Next episode, it's again my turn to talk about a World Heritage Site. I can give a bit of a spoiler — we're gonna stay in Europe, we're gonna actually talk about an island, not just a peninsula, but a full island, the next time. So, hope you're gonna tune in again, and until then, take care, and goodbye!
Lina: Goodbye.