St Kilda: Life on the Edge of the World
Millenia of Isolation, Undone in a Single Day
Show notes
St Kilda isn't just a remote, wind-battered island chain off the edge of Scotland — it's one of only a handful of places on Earth recognized by UNESCO for both its culture and its nature at once, and the site of one of the most remarkable, self-sufficient ways of life humans have ever built on the sea's edge. This episode is the first of our new season, and it left even us a little haunted.
Corrections & Clarifications
We're rookies, so we like to keep ourselves honest — a few things from this episode worth clarifying:
What actually killed Mary Gillies, the woman whose death became the final catalyst for the evacuation? In the episode, we say she was initially diagnosed with appendicitis. That was the long-assumed cause for decades — but in 1991 her son, Norman Gillies, established that she actually died of pneumonia following childbirth; her newborn daughter died as well. Ralf's mention of "pregnancy complications" alongside "appendicitis" was reaching for this — the correct read is: long-assumed appendicitis, later established as pneumonia after childbirth.
Is the "36 eggs and 18 seabirds in a day" figure really a daily amount? We flagged our own uncertainty about this one on air, and that instinct was right. The 18th-century census figure this comes from is almost certainly a seasonal harvest total that got misread as a single day's intake — 18 seabirds plus 36 eggs would be an implausible amount of food for one person to eat daily on top of everything else in their diet. The scale of what these seabird colonies provided the islanders is still real; the "per day" framing likely isn't.
The cultural criteria. As a small mistake, we say verbally that St Kilda meets cultural criteria number IV, where it is actually criteria V. The given definition is though correct.
What will you learn in this episode?
- How total isolation from the mainland shaped a way of life built almost entirely around seabirds
- Why cliff fowling was one of the most dangerous jobs imaginable, and how the cleitean storage huts kept the catch through winter
- How resident ministers, tourism, and war slowly eroded a 4,000-year way of life through the 19th and early 20th centuries
- Why the 1930 evacuation of the last 36 islanders can be read as both a tragedy and an act of courage and agency
- Why St Kilda is a "mixed" World Heritage Site — and why that category is rarer than either purely cultural or purely natural sites
- What St Kilda's endemic wren, mouse, dandelion, and genetically distinct Soay and Boreray sheep reveal about evolution in isolation
- How to actually plan a visit: charter boats, weather-dependent crossings, self-sufficiency, and strict biosecurity rules
Sources for our research
- Official UNESCO St Kilda Page
- Community for World Heritage Travellers — St Kilda
- Wikipedia — St Kilda, Scotland
- National Trust for Scotland — St Kilda
- National Trust for Scotland — St Kilda Introduction Talk for Visitors (YouTube)
- National Trust for Scotland — Media Release: A Bird's-Eye View of the Gannet Colony at St Kilda Reveals New Stats
- IUCN World Heritage Outlook — St Kilda
- BBC News- Last surviving St Kildan Rachel Johnson dies
- St Kilda: Britain's Loneliest Isle — 1928 Documentary Film (YouTube)
- Ruth Aisling — Visiting the Evacuated Scottish Island: St Kilda (YouTube)
If you enjoyed this episode, follow us on Instagram at @worldheritagerookies for visuals, fun facts, and hints about our next destinations.
Have questions or your own St Kilda stories? Send us a message — we'd love to hear from you! Don't forget to follow or subscribe to the podcast so you never miss an episode. Next episode, Lina takes the lead — to her and Ralf's favorite World Heritage Site of all, one both of them have actually visited. Any guesses where we're going?
Show transcript
Ralf: St. Kilda, a remote island off Scotland's coast, was occupied by humans for more than 4000 years, until one day in 1930, when the last islanders left it forever.
Lina: Before that, the islanders built their entire way of living around sea birds, which is just one reason St. Kilda is one of these rare mixed World Heritage sites, valued for both culture and nature.
Ralf: Today we talk about St. Kilda's very special way of communication, its history, the islanders' final decision and essential travel tips. Let's sail out to St. Kilda, right after the intro.
Ralf: Welcome to World Heritage Rookies, the podcast where we explore UNESCO World Heritage sites one episode at a time. We are Ralf,
Lina: and Lina, and we'll take you along to some of the most remarkable places on our planet.
Ralf: Each episode we dig into the history, the occasional controversy and why these sites matter, sharing our own discoveries and travel tips along the way.
Lina: So let's get exploring World Heritage together.
Lina: Hi, everyone. Welcome to our 13th episode of World Heritage Rookies. If you're listening for the first time, well, we are just starting a new season, so welcome.
Ralf: And if you have been listening to past episodes, welcome back. We appreciate it really that you are joining us again for another episode. And yeah, as Lina mentioned, we are now sort of starting our second season selection, however you want to call it. I guess a lot of you have figured out the first 12 episodes that we did, they were all about the first 12 World Heritage Sites that were inscribed in the year 1978. And we thought, you know what, that's actually a good number.
Lina: Let's spice it up, that's what we think we are doing.
Ralf: Yeah, we thought, okay, let's keep it, like, always presenting, like, in each season, 12 sites that have something that they share. And, spoiler, it's not going to be the year this time, these next 12 sites. Let's just say, pay attention to the criteria.
Lina: It's like a game, and the intention is that you kind of guess what the next 12 episodes are all about. Though I think we are pretty obvious, and you will see it through the 12 episodes — we are not really not giving clues, let's see.
Ralf: That's true, yeah. And, yeah, so, very excited we're starting off today.
Lina: And we have other news, from this episode on, just because we really enjoy our first 12 episodes, but we also have to admit it was quite...
Ralf: Research intensive.
Lina: Research intense. Yes, we decided to do our podcast now bi-weekly. And, yes, I hope that, well, we will have less content, but you will have more time to listen to us, and maybe also re-listen to us.
Ralf: I actually got from some of our friends that complained that they are not able to catch up with all the episodes at the moment with this. So, that's basically a service to our listeners. You're welcome, you have more time to catch up with previous episodes.
Lina: So, you're basically saying that this is for them, not for us?
Ralf: I'm trying to do everything so I can sell it better. No, but, yeah, jokes aside, I guess also we have sort of, like, extended what we're talking about in these episodes. So, we realize it takes more research, and therefore, also to ensure that we make it properly, more fact-checking, more everything, we want to give it the time that it deserves. And, therefore, in the future, we will release our episodes bi-weekly, but not this episode. Throughout this episode, you will listen to, right now, me talking about the 13th World Heritage Site in our podcast.
Lina: So, what are we talking about?
Ralf: We are going to talk about St. Kilda, and I have to admit, I'm quite looking forward to describing this to you, because it surprised me a lot during the research, and I will share with you, let's say, really a story of a place that is very, very remote, and therefore has a very specific way of life of the people that lived there for a long time that sort of came crashing down in one tragic event in the 20th century. And it is probably the most unique way of living that I have encountered in my research so far. So, I'm quite curious what you will think about it when we're done with this episode.
Lina: Yes. I'm like, good.
Ralf: Okay, blown away, like I already said, I made you speechless.
Lina: Wow.
Ralf: Perhaps that actually is a good transition. So, before this episode and the little tease that I gave you, what did you know about St. Kilda?
Lina: So, well, it's not much what I know. I know it's on the north coast of Scotland, because I saw it in a map. I kind of spoil myself that. I also know it's an island. Surprise, surprise. And I also know that it's a little bit too far away, so I wonder what type of, like, development and civilization was going on in that place. But I guess now you're going to tell me.
Ralf: That's actually a very good transition because this remoteness is in a way what made St Kilda special the way it is. But yes, you're right. So St Kilda is generally considered as one of the most outward parts of the British Isles. So it is a really remote volcanic archipelago in the North Atlantic, which is about 66 kilometers, or for our American friends, 41 miles west of an island formation called the Outer Hebrides of Scotland. And it is generally, like, yeah, you have one of the main islands, which is called Hirta, and this is the one that becomes important later. You have some other smaller islands around it and some other pieces and chunks of rock that come in this area. And, yes, so it's a really remote place.
Lina: Is there any reason why it's called Hirta? Because that sounds like an old Norse-y female name, but I'm not sure if this is the reason or if there is something else.
Ralf: I did not find so much out about the naming of the islands by themselves. So I actually also know that there is a bit of uncertainty why the whole formation is called St Kilda. So there is not an agreed upon thesis. There are multiple ideas why it's called, I guess, but there is not really a generally agreed upon reason for this. So I did unfortunately not find out why it was called Hirta.
Ralf: So coming a little bit into the history — in quotation marks — about the place, always when we're talking about something with some natural influence, we are spoiling it with, well, one of the reasons why it's a World Heritage Site also has to do with nature. But, so the islands by themselves, they are the remnants of an ancient, eroded volcanic area. So it is believed that it is also, for example, home today to Britain's highest sea cliffs, at a place called Conachair, which are about 430 meters high, and just going straight into the Atlantic. When you take a look at some pictures of it, which we're going to share on our companion post at our Instagram @worldheritagerookies,
Lina: Social media time!
Ralf: then you will see what I mean. So, it has really harsh cliffs, and apparently this is all because it was in the past part of a volcanic plateau that existed there. And obviously over all the millennia, it has eroded with the influence of the weather forces. And that is also going to be relevant when I talk about history later, because even despite it being so far out in the Atlantic Ocean, there are actually traces that human habitation, or at least human visitors, around there already happened like four to five thousand years in the past. So, they found Bronze Age stone tools and Iron Age remnants in different sites of the area. So, it is believed that even in antiquity, people have braved all the dangers and really harsh conditions of the ocean around there to travel to this area. It's not 100% sure when the first permanent people would live there, but at least that they would pass by.
Lina: Are you trying to tell me that Vikings were also probably there?
Ralf: That is not 100% proven, but it is quite highly suspected. So, the problem we have especially — if I get the historic records of St. Kilda correct — is that early written records are really scarce. So, generally, it's assumed the first mention of it might be from an Icelandic cleric in the year 1202, and even that is debated. They are suspecting, yes, Vikings might have been there, and that is because for a very long time the inhabitants of St. Kilda spoke a really unique, highly localist dialect that had parts of first the Scottish Gaelic language, but also traces of Old Norse. So, this is giving you the suspicion Vikings might have had an influence, but that's what I mentioned — we cannot say for sure. There are a lot of clues, but not distinctive records or any kind of materials that really prove for 100% that this has happened there. Sorry to disappoint you — no, not 100% that Vikings were there.
Lina: It's okay, it's okay. I am used to your disappointment.
Ralf: Okay, I hope....
Lina: Historical disappointment.
Ralf: Yeah, I hope we're just, like, saying, about things that I talk about in this podcast, but, yes.
Ralf: But, yeah, as you can imagine, just also from me highlighting how rare it was to have a mention of this place in historical accounts — it is because, well,
Lina: Because it's super remote.
Ralf: It's super remote, and the community there was really entirely isolated from mainland politics, wars, and international affairs. So I read in multiple records that it was more than one time mentioned that those people were just simply not aware of what was going on — well, first, the mainland of the British Isles, or, like, just broader Europe. But that led to these very unique ways of living, also. So, for example, for a very long time, it was mentioned that in the early spirituality, there was a blend of deep communal Christianity — obviously impacted by factors coming from the mainland — but still mixed with older naturalistic beliefs, in prehistoric sort of Drudic pagan rituals.
Ralf: That were remnants of the really early beginnings of the suspected first civilizations that were part of St. Kilda. And as you also saw before, because of being so distant out and also the surrounding waters not being super safe, what also, sort of, contributed to this isolation was that until the late 19th century, when also, obviously, the ships and the whole seafaring topics were getting a bit more powerful and could brave the weather better, getting there was really super dangerous and a nightmare. So, there was an account from the year 1697 that described a really dangerous open boat journey that could take weeks, coming from the closest main island areas to St. Kilda. And, especially between the months of September and March, violent winter storms could basically make the whole journey impossible, because it was just so dangerous to cross towards St. Kilda. And, therefore, it was another factor that was benefiting, or contributing to, this whole isolation thing. Actually, as a fun fact, what I read — it was never really populated. So, even at the suspected peak, the population was supposed to be something below 200 inhabitants. So, I read between 180 to 200 people living there at the peak period on the island. So, it was a really special case in itself, yes.
Lina: What makes this place, well, it's really interesting, is that they were self-sustained, right? Because they couldn't get products from the land, so they had to pretty much exist with the resources that the island provided itself. Even if it's 200 people, they had to sustain food and water and all these kind of necessary things for 200 people for the longest time.
Ralf: That's correct. And how do you think they did that?
Lina: I don't know. I would assume water from rain, so I guess that they had to collect rainwater — this is just an assumption. And, well, it's a volcanic land, so I don't know if this could have helped also to make a little bit more of a nutrient-heavy soil. But, or maybe just hunting and fishing — it can be a little bit of everything, I guess, but I'm not really sure. How did they survive there?
Ralf: Well, the first instincts are definitely correct, but they had a very unique way of surviving there. So, they used, as I understood, did some kind of farming and also had some cattle, but not that much, because actually the whole surrounding — the whole island — is not that easy for plants, mostly, as I learned, because of the conditions with the wind and everything around the seaside, so they were able to use some really hardy crops, or some hardy plants, that could withstand the not-so-good environment around there. Fishing was also basically out of the option, what I read, because of the waters around it being so dangerous and treacherous. So, they had a very, very unique way of surviving, which was seabirds.
Lina: Seabirds?
Ralf: Yeah. So, the islands of St. Kilda, until today, are one of the most populated, well, living areas of seabird populations in the area. So, in a way, all of these seabirds sort of function as a natural farm for the inhabitants. So, the islanders relied almost entirely on the colonies of all the different seabirds you can find there, like gannets, fulmars, and puffins, for example. And I found there actually a very interesting side note, which I do not know if I want to fully believe, but there was apparently a census taken about the populations in Scotland, and that also included St. Kilda, and that said that at the peak of a summer day, a single islander — so only one person — could consume an average of 36 wild fowl eggs and 18 seabirds a day. So, one person consuming 36 eggs and 18 birds a day. I am not 100% sure if this is for some reason exaggerated. So, I looked up the source again, specifically to check if I misread it — no, they say that was consumed by one person. So, multiply this by 200 at the peak, and then you can imagine how much eggs and birds they would consume, allegedly.
Lina: So, basically their whole energy, or the whole food, was just birds, like...
Ralf: The majority of their topics, apparently, was derived from birds. So, they would eat the eggs and they would eat the birds themselves. So, for example, sometimes young birds were eaten fresh, or they were cured and made more long-term sustainable for winter. They would also use other parts of the birds as resources. So, for example, the northern fulmar, which is one of the more popular birds around there, was actually considered one of the most precious resources — in quotation marks — around there, because they used its oil for lamps, for waterproofing their things, and they used it also for medicine. Bird feathers were used, for example, as trading goods, and could also, for example, be used to make fillings for bedding, or other materials there. So, they would really rely on nearly everything from the bird population around there. But, as you can imagine, it's not so easy to catch birds, especially when they are probably around these kind of sea cliffs,
Lina: They can fly.
Ralf: They can fly, yeah, and...
Lina: And fly away.
Ralf: And one of the reasons — again, what I mentioned before — is that you have these really deep volcanic rocks and cliffs out of the ocean, so you would normally have a lot of those birds nesting, or staying, on the cliff sides. So, in order to catch them, you would need to hunt for them on those cliff sides, and that was a really dangerous job. So, the men of the village would have to go barefoot and really scale down the 400-meter cliffs, lowered by ropes made from horsehair, using long rods, in order to get the birds and perhaps try to snatch them out of the air. So, this was a really dangerous way of surviving, but it's something the population has apparently perfectly adapted to.
Lina: I wonder one thing. So, if people that catch fish are called fishers, does that mean they were birders?
Ralf: I do not know how you would call them normally, but, yeah, if it's easrt for you, they were birders, yeah.
Lina: Birders, wow, well, yes, sounds really dangerous.
Ralf: Bird hunters, yeah. And, yeah, so, obviously, as you can also imagine, they would try it, and perhaps over time make sure that — well, when we're hunting something, we're not directly using it — then we want to make sure that we can store it somewhere. So, and this is, for example, why, until today, you will find on the island structures that are called cleitean. I'm not sure if I'm pronouncing it 100% correctly. So, they are basically storage huts made out of stone, which are designed in a way so that the wind blows through them, and that would dry out the meat, while at the same time keeping the rain out. And, until today, it's assumed that you find over 1,400 of those domes still in the archipelago area, which were used to store food in the past
Lina: yeah, like a fridge of the medievals
Ralf: Sort of a fridge in a storage way, yeah. Right, so this is a little bit of the background of, like, how far back really, centuries life has been on St. Kilda.
Ralf: And coming a bit to the development in the later centuries — especially the 19th century — it brought massive social upheaval to the area, as more and more influence from the outside world was going into St Kilda's isolation. You have to imagine, before, contact with the outside world had been really difficult. Do you have any idea how they could have tried to communicate with the outside world?
Lina: I mean, my most obvious thought is through letters, sent by boat, of course, especially for the longest time. But I hope they use, I don't know, I think about some bottles with some messages inside and throw them into the sea. But, maybe also, like, birds — because, I mean, they had a bunch of them, so, put some messages on their feet and fly away? I don't know.
Ralf: Well, I think the majority of the birds was to use as food, but you actually — your first clue was quite correct with the boats, so, um.
Lina: Ah no, the boring answer, okay.
Ralf: The boring answer, I'm sorry. So, for a very long time, they would use something which was actually called St Kilda mail boats. So, they would carve small wooden boats, hollow them out, to hold a message in a bottle. Then they would attach it to a sealed sheep's bladder, that would then sort of act as a float, and then they would drop it into the water and, well, hope it comes to the mainland.
Lina: Wait, wait, wait. So, you're basically saying it's a combination between my answer number one and my answer number two? So, it was, like, a boat, but, a long boat with bottles, messages.
Ralf: Yeah, so, it was, like, small messages in a bottle that they were tying then to a sheep's bladder, and then afterwards — so, sheep, the animal, meh — and then hoping that it comes to the mainland.
Lina: Do you want to explain why you did this clarification?
Ralf: No, no, no, I just think it's important that everybody understands my correct pronunciation, obviously. Um, yes, but all of this sort of changed more and more in the 19th century. So, first thing that was shaping a lot what happened on the islands was that a series of resident ministers — so, holy people coming over to the islands — they would change the island life, and there are especially three mentioned throughout the history. First is a gentleman called Reverend John MacDonald in the 1820s who really thoroughly tried to convert the islanders more and more to the Christian beliefs. As you remember what I told before, they had been influenced for a very long time by the sort of combination of Christianity and pagan beliefs. But, was apparently not so easy, but generally he is still considered as somebody that was perceived quite well towards the population. And then, one of the biggest impacts has been attributed to Reverend Neil Mackenzie in the 1830s, who was putting a lot of effort into trying to reorganize the way of living, and especially the way that they conducted farming. So, he tried to build it into more of a structured village approach, and actually the layout that you can still see today of the old village is still based on the changes that he brought to the island. And he also was really focused on bringing more formal education towards the island, and trying to advance it a bit more towards the modern times. So, he is generally, as I found from the research, perceived quite positively. And then you have mentioned also a gentleman called Reverend John Mackay, who was a bit more of a zealot and, yeah, tried, like, to bring more brutally the religious observance there. Like, so, for example, making sure that everybody would have to mandatorily attend Sunday church services. He would ban games, music, and leisure on the Sabbath. So, he was a bit more towards the strict rule of the church. And therefore, of course, as I understood, not that positively viewed,
Lina: Not that popular.
Ralf: Yeah, but so...
Lina: You don't take music from the people.
Ralf: No, don't take music from the people. And especially — I mean, like, when I'm sitting here with somebody coming from a culture where music is so important — that is simply not a good idea.
Lina: Yeah, no, no, no. Don't, don't ever do that in Latin America, please.
Ralf: Yeah, you will not be well-received, but, so those kinds of changes were, like, obviously impacting first the way of living for the better or for the worse. And as you can imagine, life on this island was never really easy, because you had to mostly rely on what the island would provide. You have a very harsh climatic environment, driven by this isolation and this presence in the Atlantic Ocean. And with also more and more influence coming in from the outside, and the people realizing there, well, how is life on the outside compared to how life is on the island, you would have more and more people also going away, with the perspective, okay, I can find an easier life somewhere else, especially when I see how people from the mainland are living. And this led, for example, to one disastrous event in the year 1852, where 36 islanders — so remember, at the peak, there were 200 people, so 36 leaving —
Lina: So yes, it gives 164 left.
Ralf: So we do not know if, by the time these people left, the population might have already been lower. What I'm saying is, 36 people leaving is a large chunk of people needed to make life on this island worth living, or livable. So, they tried to emigrate to Australia. Tragically, 18 of those people died on the route or in quarantine, and these were especially young people. And, as you can imagine, the island's population has never really recovered from the sudden loss of, well, people needed to ensure that you can survive, because remember what I said before, you needed also to be really physically fit and active to ensure you could hunt those seabirds in all the areas.
Lina: Yeah, maybe they were — that's why they were so annoyed about it, they didn't want to eat more bird anymore — but no, joke aside, do you have any information on why they chose Australia? Because, I mean, from Scotland to Australia, they couldn't choose something farther away, you know what I mean? It's a really distant location.
Ralf: I do not know specifically what the reason was for them to emigrate to Australia. I think they mentioned that the boat they were on was going to Australia — perhaps it was just, at this time, an opportunity for them to go, and it was specifically this boat saying, okay, hey, we're going to Australia if you want to come. If I find it afterwards, I will add it in the shownotes as an additional description, but then I will have to check again. Yeah.
Lina: I see
Ralf: So this was one thing where the influence of the outside world really impacted how St. Kilda was developing. Two other things were, for example, as it became more and more easier to reach the island via steamboats, then also tourism started to boom more. So, I mentioned already before that they would, for example, use feathers as trading elements and other things. But the problem that was also coming with this is that tourists sort of started to see the people of St. Kilda more like animals in a zoo, sort of, because they were so unique in their way of living, or in the perspective of the mainlanders, so primitive. They would, for example, show behaviors like throwing coins at them, or really just making them feel like they were more animals or curiosities compared to humans. And I think I do not have to tell you what this can also do to your perception as a human being, and how you are feeling towards yourself. This kind of humiliation is another negative impact that, unfortunately, outside contact brought to them.
Lina: Yeah, no, no. And I can imagine, of course, people seeing you as an animal — that has to be one of the most degrading things for a human. And it's not the first case, so I guess that's the problem with many of our societies — everything that is a little bit different, a different upbringing, creates chaos and wrong perception.
Ralf: And also, with more and more people arriving from the outside, diseases were brought more inside.
Lina: Of course.
Ralf: So, if this also happens then — if we're now jumping more into the 20th century — then unfortunately also wars and everything happened. So, for example, during World War One, they built a naval station there, which would then, on the good side, bring really daily communication and a taste of the modern world to St. Kilda, but also, on the downside, would make the island sort of a target, because in 1918, a German U-boat actually surfaced and attacked the island, which destroyed the wireless station. Thankfully, nobody died apart from a sheep, so.
Lina: Wait, what? A sheep?
Ralf: Yeah, a sheep died from the shelling, so luckily no human lives were lost, but, a quick moment of silence for that sheep that got destroyed by the attack of a German U-boat.
Lina: Doo-doo-doo-doo-doo-doo-doo.
Ralf: Yeah. But, okay — the horrible moment of silence, I realized.
Ralf: But this actually made an issue that we mentioned before even worse, because then you would have young men that were also part of the war, and then, during this war, they experienced mainland life and the perceived abundance that they would find there. And then, when they returned, the brutal lifestyle of St. Kilda had even more lost its appeal. So, you had even more young people leaving the island for good wages and better living conditions, which would leave, in the end, really an aging, vulnerable population.
Ralf: And the real breaking point is very often associated with an event that happened in January 1930, where a young woman with the name of Mary Gillies fell deathly ill. She was eventually evacuated to the mainland, but unfortunately there she died, along with her newborn, apparently because of pregnancy complications. So, what — if I understood correctly — she had initially been diagnosed with appendicitis, and because they could not help her on the island, she was eventually brought to the mainland, but by then it was too late. And this, apparently, was the last straw that shattered the resolve of the community, because it was just even more shown that, with an aging population especially, they were now in danger of not being able to ensure timely medical care.
Ralf: And that actually — the remaining 36 islanders collectively asked the government to evacuate them, which happened then, actually, on August 29th of the year 1930. And on this date, an estimated 4,000 years of human activity on St. Kilda ended, because since then, there's been no permanent population, in a way, on the island. So, at the moment, it is still used by the military, and you have some researchers based there, but this is more, like, some temporary settlement, or inhabitation there. And what I found is sort of, like, bittersweet — they left, apparently, a plate of oats and an open Bible in every cottage, boarded a ship, and never returned back there, apart from occasional visits, as I understood. And actually, the last surviving original St. Kildan, by the name of Rachel Johnson, died in the year 2016.
Lina: In 2016.
Ralf: Yeah, so she was still a very young woman when all of this happened, but she is currently believed to be the last person who was born on St. Kilda and that died then, and this is sort of also what I would like to discuss with you, because I have found different ways how this evacuation is perceived in the sources I took a look at. So, for some, it's, like, saying, well, it's only a pragmatic way of thinking, and basically accepting that your way of living has come to an end. And others were more describing it as a tragedy, as I mentioned before — like, you had for thousands of years people living on this island, despite all these hard conditions, and now, in one day, it stopped. How do you see this event of the evacuation of St. Kilda — how do you perceive it? Is it a tragedy? Is it a pragmatic solution? Is it the way of life? What is it for you?
Lina: I just think that it's understandable that the living conditions were too hard. I mean, the realization for a population to leave your home is never easy — let's put that in, as a first statement. But the realization that these 36 inhabitants — like, we cannot sustain this way of living anymore. We don't have enough population to sustain the help between elderly and younger, and the fact that they didn't have any real medical assistance — it's just a combination of factors that made it impossible not to think about leaving. I think that it's not the first case in human history where populations have to leave a place, and it sometimes is inevitable.
Ralf: Cannot be avoided.
Lina: Cannot be avoided. So, I just think this is one of those cases where, unfortunately, this was the only solution. And in the end of the day, yes, it's really sad, because historically, well, you're saying it's 4,000, years of history, but at the same time, as a survival method, it's totally reasonable that they decided to leave.
Ralf: I think it's also a very brave decision, because, in the end, you are willing to accept and say, you know what, our way of living might not work out for us anymore. And as you said, I believe it cannot have been easy to make this decision, but to come then, in the end, to the conclusion, we are not able to continue like this — that takes a lot of courage, in my opinion. It is actually a very good example of, I would say, agency for the population — that they could make this decision, and that then also the government supported them with the evacuation. So, that's why, for me personally, framing it as a tragedy is a wrong way of perceiving it, in my opinion. It's, of course, it's a shame that this way of living has disappeared. You could argue the same with all lost civilizations and lost ways of living. And just because something has disappeared, it doesn't make it less valuable for having existed.
Lina: I mean, let's think about it the other way you say — maybe without them moving, this lady would not have survived until 2016. That would have probably been impossible. And they just gave themselves an opportunity to live longer and enjoy a little bit more of life.
Ralf: That's true. So, I think that's a very good way to perceive what happened in St. Kilda. Yes, so this is a little bit about the history and interesting facts that I learned during my research of St. Kilda.
Ralf: I'm coming now to our main section, always from a World Heritage Traveler perspective — the criteria. So, you sort of know which direction you're in, but how many criteria do you think it meets?
Lina: Um, more than five.
Ralf: It is actually five. Yeah. So, first thing, it is a mixed World Heritage Site. For our audience who might not know, mixed World Heritage Sites are World Heritage Sites that meet both natural criteria and cultural criteria. So, that means a World Heritage Site can be either only cultural, only natural, or it can have factors of both, which makes it then a mixed World Heritage Site. So, they are by far the least common category of World Heritage Sites. You have far less mixed World Heritage, compared to natural and cultural. I think that the cultural World Heritage Sites are also quite by far the ones that are exceeding — around, they're like nearly a thousand or so at the moment of recording, are cultural. Then you have something between 200 and 250, if I remember correctly, that are natural World Heritage Sites, and mixed World Heritage Sites are, like, really below 50, so it's quite rare. And at least at the time of recording, this is actually the only mixed World Heritage Site in the United Kingdom.
Lina: So, I mean, it is interesting, because something that our audience also has to understand is that it's really normal for a cultural site to not become a mixed environmental site, because it is supposed to stay like that. So, in order for a cultural site to become, for instance, also a natural site, that means that nature has to take over, and this carries a certain level of risk, of course, of destroying the cultural part and the historical part. So, that's why it's really uncommon, and it's really good to see one of those sites here today.
Ralf: Yes, it is really uncommon and this why they are comparably rare because the balance is something that is really difficult to achieve, I have to admit. I think we also, in our visits, have not been to so many mixed ones, because it is quite difficult too. But yes, as I mentioned, so, it's meeting five criteria, and for the cultural criteria, the first one is criteria number three, which is, sort of, a testimony to a way of living. And, as you can imagine, it is recognized as a very exceptional testimony to a disappeared way of living, having been able to survive for millennia in extreme conditions. And so, this is why it's meeting criteria number three. And it's also meeting criteria number five, as an historic example, because the — until now preserved — 19th century village layout, and also those dry stone storage huts that I mentioned before, they represent a really incredible way of showcasing a seabird economy and land use which is found nowhere else.
Ralf: But the main criteria actually within, as you can guess, are the natural ones.
Lina: The birds.
Ralf: The birds, exactly.
Lina: The sheep — I'm not talking about the boats, they are the sheep.
Ralf: So, well, more or less. So, it meets three natural criteria. So, the first is criteria number seven, which is generally about the natural beauty, and this is reflecting what I mentioned before, about this really dramatic volcanic landscape, with towering sea cliffs that are just peaking out from the Atlantic Ocean. Again, we will need to put a picture of this on our Instagram, so you can really understand how it looks. And then, as you correctly mentioned, is the whole topic of the uniqueness of it — so, that's criteria number nine. I do not know if you could go so far as to call it the Galápagos Islands of the North, because the Galápagos are still just a very special place, but also, the deep isolation that you have there has really resulted in a unique evolutionary situation. So, the island has really its own unique specific animal species. So, it has, for example, specific species of mice, and they have a distinct Saint Kildan wren, and they have even their own dandelion species, identified in 2012. So, just the life that has been born on this island and specifically adapted to this isolated way of living is very unique. And then, yeah, criteria number 10, for the whole topic of biodiversity and conservation. So, it is, until today, one of the most important bird sanctuaries within Europe, hosting, I assume, nearly a million seabirds during its peak seasons, including some of the United Kingdom's largest colonies of birds like Atlantic puffins, or breeding pairs of northern gannets. So, it is, until today, super important for these kinds of animals. And what I also found interesting is that on these islands, you can actually find sort of living relics — until today they are home to rare primitive sheep, the animals, not the transportation devices, which are called the Soay and Boreray sheep. They are, until today, unique, in a way, because they have remained genetically pure — in quotation marks — since the Neolithic and Iron Ages, not having been, in a way, affected by domestication and influence from humans. And that's why, until today, these small islands are considered a very interesting observation ground, if you are interested in these kinds of animals.
Lina: Go and see the sheeps.
Ralf: Exactly. Unfortunately, as with everything that is a natural World Heritage Site, there are threats to it. I guess you can assume what some of those might be, right?
Lina: Of course — contamination, and I guess also excessive use of, like, marine boats around, maybe?
Ralf: That, luckily, is actually not one, because with the majority of the humans gone, it is not that horrible anymore. But, if we look at the outlook from the IUCN, which is an organization that is specifically looking out for, well, what's the status quo of natural heritage sites, so there are three main challenges. One that you mentioned before is, yeah, climate change, and how everything is impacted with pollution. So, the North Atlantic, also around St Kilda, is warming up, and warmer waters are changing the whole ecosystem around there — for example, reducing the availability of small fish that, on the other hand, are required as food for a lot of the seabirds around there to feed themselves and also their chicks. So, warmer waters are a danger, unfortunately, for the whole ecosystem around there. Unfortunately, also the avian flu — especially in recent years, massive outbreaks of avian flu have ravaged the seabird populations globally, and also on St Kilda, unfortunately. And I do not directly know if this can be tied to climate change, but what is also mentioned is an increasing amount of extreme weather conditions. So, you have higher and more intense storms that are damaging and threatening the whole landscape around there, especially those historic stone storages that I mentioned before, and the remaining village structures. So this is what is threatening the more cultural part of the World Heritage. Yeah.
Lina: Is the government actively preserving these sites — especially the storage huts and the villages — or is it really completely empty? And is it expected that one day the cultural part will just basically disappear due to weather conditions?
Ralf: I mean, considering it's a World Heritage Site, and therefore there are also conservation measures part of it — because if this stuff would disappear, then we have to remember, the village and storage units are a reason why it's at least a cultural heritage. So, they have to be protected in some ways. Obviously, when we're talking about thousands of those constructions, you will never be able to fully mitigate the impact of weather on these kinds of structures and conditions, compared to when an island is actually still lived on. So, I know there are at the moment, especially researchers and military, who are still active there. So my assumption is that you will also have these people then as responsible for taking care, at least, or people will also come there to take care of it. So, but you will not be able to protect the whole island with just a bunch of temporary residents on the island here.
Lina: Yeah.
Ralf: That's actually a good transition into the last part, which is, okay, what happens when you want to travel there? It's, as you can imagine, not so easy.
Lina: It's difficult and expensive, Ralf?
Ralf: It is difficult for sure — expensive, I have not found so much information about the price range, which is also not giving me so much confidence. Yeah. Because normally when you're not talking about prices, it means they are high. But, yeah, what you have to take from this mainly, I would say, is it takes really planning in advance.
Ralf: So getting there is difficult. So it's accessible only by small charter boats, mostly leaving from places like Harris, Uist, or the Isle of Skye. It's assumed that the crossing takes about two and a half to four hours, depending on where you're coming from, across an open, often very violent ocean — we also have to remember. And because, especially later in the year, the weather conditions are becoming more and more unpredictable, it can really be that boat crossings are canceled because it's too dangerous. So, you need to know — on the one hand, plan in advance, but also prepare to be flexible, because it might be that it's canceled because of weather conditions. That's why it's generally assumed that the best time to visit is around late May and the month of June, because that's generally when the seas are the calmest. And it's also generally assumed that it might be the best time period for birdwatching, which is one of the main activities you can expect to do on the island.
Lina: Also, I guess the climate on the island is at its most mild during those times.
Ralf: Yeah, as mild as it can get there, because, again, as I heard, with all the seaside around there, and winds and storms,
Lina: It's really never mild.
Ralf: it is probably milder, but not mild as you might expect from other places.
Lina: Yeah, it's not a perfect spring day.
Ralf: Exactly, yeah.
Ralf: And also, when you arrive there, be aware you basically have to be completely self-sufficient. So, there are no restaurants, there are no cafes — again, you have to remind yourself, there is no permanent population on these islands. You must be completely self-sufficient. You can, theoretically, camp there, as I understood, so you have to also register for this in advance. But when you are going camping there, you have to bring your own food, and you have to make sure that you bring your own material and assets in order to survive there. You should definitely bring waterproof and sturdy boots and general clothing, because there is not anything there where you can go to a shopping center and just get clothes or food. So, there is — what I learned — luckily, there's a public toilet there, at least.
Lina: Yeah, but nobody's gonna clean it, for sure.
Ralf: Well, let's hope that you're not gonna clog it, for sure. And there's also, apparently, a small souvenir shop, which is basically run on trust. So, you can take a souvenir, and you are then asked to leave a small donation for it in exchange. So, that is — even though you have a souvenir shop, you still do not have a shopkeeper regularly there taking care of it.
Lina: But that's quite adorable. Imagine having a small gift from one of the most remote locations in the world.
Ralf: As I understand, it's actually found in cottage number three, which is — if I read correctly — either the only home that is fully open to the public among the remnants of the village, or one of the few. I think it's actually the only one that is open, and it has now been turned into a museum to sort of showcase how life was there during that time. And I think in one of the rooms there is where you find the souvenir shop if I understood it correctly and this is actually one of the main activities you will do on the island. You can walk through the streets of the abandoned village, look at some of the houses and explore how it was. The houses will be in different shapes, so there will be some who are in better conditions and some that are already more crumbling. Only one of them, as I understood, this cottage number three can still be visited. You will be able to walk through the landscape, obviously see some of those storage units, which you can look at from the outside, especially because when you crawl inside, don't forget, they might be unstable. Don't do this — just admire them from the outside — to hike towards the cliff sides around there, to look at the amazing landscape and the birds, and observe them.
Ralf: Also, just something very important to consider — don't forget, it's still really a sanctuary for birds. So, you have to go through a lot of biosecurity measures, in a way, and show respect towards the wildlife there. So, you're not allowed to bring any drones, you're not allowed to bring any pets, you have to go through strict biosecurity boot-cleaning when you arrive at the island, to make sure the ecosystem is protected, that you're not bringing any kind of germs or so. And, again, to highlight here — due to the risk of avian flu, absolutely do not touch any birds.
Lina: Don't eat the birds.
Ralf: Don't eat the birds. Do not try to come back to the lifestyle of the St. Kildans — admire them from a distance, a safe distance, both for you and for the birds. And, yes, that's sort of the gist and the main highlights of St. Kilda. It's one, I have to admit, for me, very surprising World Heritage Site, and when you learn more about it, then you understand why it's special. But it left me a bit with a haunting tale — like, in one hand, like I mentioned before, it's a sad tale, but on the other hand, also a bit of a tale that tells you about the victory of agency of the population. But it's a very interesting site for me, I have to admit.
Lina: It is really interesting. I think that one of the things that I would like to see is this pure-blood sheep — sounds amazing, they sound really cool. But, yeah, it is a really interesting place. It is, I guess, that the question you're going to ask is, like, would we like to go. Personally, of course, I would like something from this gift shop, for sure. I want to see the birds, I want to see — because there have to be many, so amazing, amazing views, also for the cliffs that you mentioned. But also, realistic in a sense, could be really difficult. Because you need to be aware of the flexibility that you need and also the cost and time driving conditions.
Ralf: I think for us it's nearly never the question "Do we want to go?", because we would want to go probably to every place we mentioned, but, like, realistically speaking, do we see us going in the next five or six years, and then, I would probably say for St. Kilda?
Lina: Probably no. Nevertheless, if you have the opportunity, we would really like to hear your experience — it sounds like an amazing place, so if you have the opportunity, don't think twice. And, yeah, I hope that if we cannot go, I hope you guys go.
Ralf: At least that, yeah. And, as Lina said, if you have been, please share the insights — obviously, we read some travel reports, I watched some YouTube videos about people who have been there, but I think I would also be really curious to hear from people who have actually been. And, yes.
Lina: Especially people who have recently experienced it, you know — that's quite interesting, to see how, from today's perspective, tourists and people actually visit the island.
Ralf: All right, and that's the end of the first episode of our second season.
Ralf: Next episode, it's your turn, and you're under a bit of pressure, right?
Lina: I'm under a bit of pressure, because this is our favorite so far — our favorite World Heritage Site. It's one of the first World Heritage Sites we have spoken about, both of us had been there, and it's also the peak of our rating scale — because, yes, we rate our World Heritage Sites, just a little bit of information, maybe one day we can talk about how we have rated the places we have visited, for sure. But yes, I'm quite excited for you, for me, to share this information with all of you, and also motivate you to go to what is, today, one of our favorites, or our favorite World Heritage Site.
Ralf: And, so, yeah, expectations raised.
Lina: Expectations, really high, especially by my husband, because he knows a lot about this place as well, so he will be — you know, he will be picky — you will be picky.
Ralf: I'm always picky.
Lina: You will be like, mmm, did you cross-check absolutely everything, and the response is yes, tried to do it as much as I could.
Ralf: I'm very looking forward to it, I hope our audience is as well, and, until then, thank you so much for listening, take care, and see you next time.
Lina: See you next time, goodbye.
Ralf: Bye-bye.